All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Theories of law: positivism (Austin, Hart and Kelsen)
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
What makes something law? Positivists say it is the way a rule is made, not whether it is morally good. Specification point 1.1.9.
The positivist idea
For positivists a law is valid if it was made by the correct process, whatever its content. Law and morality are separate: a law can be valid even if we think it is wrong. Pearson's topic guide quotes the idea that a law which exists is a law, though we happen to dislike it.
Austin: the command theory
John Austin defined law as a command issued by a superior (the sovereign, the state) to an inferior (the individual), enforced by sanctions. The topic guide traces this back to Bentham and Hobbes.
Criticisms: much law does not command anyone and carries no sanction. Laws that confer powers, such as the rules for making a will or a contract, or regulatory law, do not fit the model, so the topic guide says Austin's definition excludes regulatory law.
Hart and Kelsen
H L A Hart (*The Concept of Law*) criticised Austin and distinguished:
- primary rules, which impose obligations (criminal law) or grant powers (contract law), and
- secondary rules, which govern how primary rules are made, changed and revoked, by Parliament and judges.
For Hart a valid legal system has processes for creating, amending and revoking law.
Hans Kelsen developed a 'pure theory of law': law is a hierarchy of norms, and a norm is valid only if the body that made it was empowered by a higher norm. He deliberately did not judge the content of norms.
Using positivism in an answer
Pearson's topic guide applies the theories to cases. In *Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech AHA* [1986] AC 112 (under-16s could be given confidential contraceptive advice), a positivist would accept the ruling because it was reached by the proper judicial process and precedent, whatever its morality. The weakness is the 'unjust law' problem: positivism struggles to say a law made by the proper process is not law even when it is deeply immoral, which is the starting point of the Hart and Fuller debate (next lesson).
Worked example
A Parliament passes a valid Act that many people think is morally wrong. What would a positivist say about its status?
- Positivists separate law and morality.
- Validity depends on the correct law-making process.
Answer: It is valid law because it was made by the correct process; whether it is moral is a separate question.
Check yourself
- The central claim of legal positivism is that
- an unjust law is not law at all
- law must promote the greatest happiness
- a law is valid if made by the correct process, whatever its content
- law comes from God
Show answer
a law is valid if made by the correct process, whatever its content. Positivists separate the validity of law from its morality.
- Austin described law as
- commands of a sovereign backed by sanctions
- primary and secondary rules
- a hierarchy of norms
- an inner morality of eight principles
Show answer
commands of a sovereign backed by sanctions. Command theory.
- In Hart's theory, the rules that set out how laws are made and changed are
- primary rules
- natural rules
- secondary rules
- moral rules
Show answer
secondary rules. Secondary rules govern the creation, change and revocation of primary rules.
- Kelsen said a norm is valid if
- it reflects divine law
- it was made by a body empowered by a higher norm
- most people obey it out of habit
- it maximises happiness
Show answer
it was made by a body empowered by a higher norm. Validity comes from authorisation by a higher norm in a hierarchy.
- Which is a common criticism of Austin's command theory?
- It says law and morality are the same
- It depends on God's law
- It ignores the role of a sovereign
- It does not explain laws that grant powers, such as making a will
Show answer
It does not explain laws that grant powers, such as making a will. Power-conferring rules command nothing and carry no sanction.
- Explain how a positivist would view the decision in Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech AHA.
Show answer
A positivist would accept it as valid law because it was made by the proper judicial process following precedent, regardless of whether it is morally right.. Pearson's topic guide: positivists would accept Gillick because it followed precedent; its morality is a separate question.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.