All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Theories of law: natural law (Aquinas and Fuller) and Hart's response
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Natural lawyers say law must meet a higher standard than the process that made it. Specification point 1.1.10.
Aquinas: law and a higher law
Thomas Aquinas held that God set laws that humans must follow. For a human law to be valid it must be consistent with higher moral values, such as divine law. A human law that conflicts with that higher law lacks true validity.
Pearson's topic guide applies this to the Abortion Act 1967: a natural lawyer might regard it as invalid because it could be said to sanction killing the unborn.
Fuller: the inner morality of law
Lon Fuller, an American critic of positivism, supported a secular, procedural natural law. Law is the enterprise of subjecting human conduct to the governance of rules, and it has an inner morality of eight principles. Laws should be:
1. general rules, not one-off decisions
2. published
3. prospective, not retrospective
4. clear
5. not contradictory
6. possible to obey
7. reasonably stable
8. applied by officials as published
A system that badly fails these is not a legal system at all. On Fuller's test the Abortion Act 1967 is valid: it is not retrospective and can be obeyed.
Hart's response and evaluation
Hart replied to Fuller from a positivist position; the topic guide describes their debate, sparked by arguments about the validity of Nazi laws, as running from 1958 to 1967. Hart accepted that law and morality often overlap but insisted that whether a rule is law and whether it is good are separate questions.
Evaluation points:
- Natural law gives a basis for saying grossly unjust laws should not be obeyed.
- But whose morality is the 'higher law'? In a diverse society people disagree (abortion is the classic example).
- Fuller's principles are procedural, so a law could meet all eight and still be unjust in content.
- Fuller's principles overlap with modern accounts of the rule of law, which also stress published, prospective, clear law.
Worked example
Parliament passes an Act making it an offence, backdated by five years, to have attended a lawful protest. Evaluate its status using Fuller.
- The law is retrospective: it breaks Fuller's third principle.
- People could not have obeyed it at the time, which breaks the principle that laws must be possible to obey.
Answer: On Fuller's test it fails the inner morality of law, so it would lack the qualities of genuine law, although a positivist would still call it valid.
Check yourself
- For Aquinas, a human law is valid only if
- it is passed by a majority in Parliament
- it carries a sanction
- it is consistent with a higher moral or divine law
- it is applied by officials
Show answer
it is consistent with a higher moral or divine law. Natural law ties validity to higher moral standards.
- Fuller's 'inner morality of law' is best described as
- a set of procedural principles a legal system must meet
- the Ten Commandments
- the will of the sovereign
- the greatest happiness principle
Show answer
a set of procedural principles a legal system must meet. Eight procedural principles, not tied to belief in God.
- Which law most clearly breaks one of Fuller's eight principles?
- A law passed by Parliament in the usual way
- A law that applies to all drivers
- A secret law that is never published
- A law with a fine as its sanction
Show answer
A secret law that is never published. Laws must be published.
- According to Pearson's topic guide, how would Fuller view the Abortion Act 1967?
- As invalid, because it conflicts with divine law
- As valid, because it is not retrospective and can be obeyed
- As invalid, because it was a private member's bill
- As valid only in Northern Ireland
Show answer
As valid, because it is not retrospective and can be obeyed. It meets his procedural principles.
- A weakness of natural law theory is that
- it ignores morality
- it says any properly made law is valid
- it has no view on unjust laws
- people in a diverse society disagree about what the higher morality requires
Show answer
people in a diverse society disagree about what the higher morality requires. Moral disagreement makes the 'higher law' contested.
- Explain the main difference between natural law and positivism.
Show answer
Natural law says a law is only valid if it meets a higher moral standard, whereas positivism says a law is valid if it was made by the correct process regardless of its morality.. Natural law links validity to morality; positivism separates them and looks at the law-making process.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- UK Supreme Court: Lord Sales, What is the rule of law and why does it matter? (Robin Cooke Lecture, 12 December 2024)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.