All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Rules and laws: certainty, enforcement and state sanction
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Families, schools and sports clubs all have rules, but only some rules are laws. Specification points 1.1.1 to 1.1.3 ask what makes the difference.
Rules and laws
Rules guide behaviour in a particular group or situation (a school, a club, a religion). They often come from custom, and breaking them brings disapproval or an informal penalty such as expulsion from a club.
Laws are the rules of the state. They apply to everyone in the country, are made through a formal process, are enforceable and carry a penalty if broken. Pearson's topic guide gives three classic definitions:
- Austin: a command from a superior (the state) to an inferior, enforced by sanctions
- Salmond: the body of principles recognised and applied by the state in administering justice
- Martin: a formal mechanism of social control
1.1.1 Certainty
People must be able to know what the law is before they act. Pearson's guide contrasts offences such as theft and burglary, which are clearly defined, with a phrase such as 'satisfactory quality' in consumer law, which is less certain and has to be interpreted case by case. Certainty matters because the law punishes or orders compensation: it would be unfair to be punished under a rule that could not be understood in advance.
1.1.2 Enforcement and 1.1.3 sanction by the state
Laws are enforced through an organised state process: the police investigate, the Crown Prosecution Service prosecutes and the courts decide. They are sanctioned by the state: breaking a criminal law can lead to imprisonment, a fine or a community punishment, and breaking a civil law can lead to an order to pay damages. Breaking a school rule usually leads only to informal consequences such as a detention.
The role of law in society follows from these features: it keeps order (social control), settles disputes peacefully, protects rights and property, and sets the framework within which people trade, work and live together.
Worked example
A tennis club expels a member for cheating; the same member is later convicted of theft. Explain why only one of these involves law.
- The club rule applies only to members and is enforced by the club.
- Theft is a rule of the state, applies to everyone, is enforced by police, the CPS and the courts, and carries a state sanction.
Answer: The theft conviction involves law: a state rule, formally enforced, with a state penalty. The expulsion is a private rule with a private penalty.
Check yourself
- Which is a law rather than a rule?
- Theft is an offence carrying a maximum prison sentence
- Students must wear blazers in assembly
- Club members must pay a subscription by May
- Children should be home by 9 pm
Show answer
Theft is an offence carrying a maximum prison sentence. Only theft is a state rule, enforced by the courts with a state sanction.
- Pearson's guide uses 'satisfactory quality' to illustrate which feature of law?
- That laws are enforced by the police
- That laws are made by Parliament
- That some legal terms are less certain than others
- That civil law uses damages
Show answer
That some legal terms are less certain than others. The phrase is less precise than an offence like theft, so it shows a limit on certainty.
- Which body decides whether to prosecute most criminal cases in England and Wales?
- The Crown Prosecution Service
- The jury
- The Law Commission
- The magistrates' legal adviser
Show answer
The Crown Prosecution Service. The CPS brings prosecutions; the police investigate and the courts decide.
- According to Austin, law is
- whatever most people believe is morally right
- a body of customs followed voluntarily
- rules set by sports governing bodies
- a command from a superior to an inferior, backed by sanctions
Show answer
a command from a superior to an inferior, backed by sanctions. Austin's command theory: sovereign, command, sanction.
- A golf club breaks no law when it punishes a member by
- imprisoning the member
- expelling the member
- fining the member under the Sentencing Act
- issuing a criminal conviction
Show answer
expelling the member. Private bodies can expel members; only the state imposes criminal sanctions.
- Give two differences between rules and laws.
Show answer
Laws apply to everyone in the state and are enforced by the courts with penalties such as fines or prison, whereas rules apply only to a group and are enforced informally, for example by expulsion.. Two of: laws apply to everyone, rules to a group; laws are made formally, rules by custom; laws are enforced by the state through police and courts, rules informally; laws carry state sanctions, rules carry disapproval or expulsion.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2019
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.