All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Legal personality: rights, duties, privileges and liabilities
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Who can sue and be sued? Specification point 1.1.4 covers the idea of a legal person and the rights and duties it carries.
Rights, duties, privileges and liabilities
- A right is an entitlement the law will protect, such as the right to have a contract performed.
- A duty is a legal obligation, such as the duty not to injure others carelessly.
- A privilege is a legal freedom or protection that ordinary rules do not give, such as the protection from defamation claims for what is said in parliamentary debates.
- A liability is legal responsibility for breaking a duty: paying damages or receiving a criminal sanction.
The Getting Started guide links these to the social contract: people accept limits on their freedom, including laws they disagree with, in return for living in an ordered community.
Natural and juridical persons
Legal personality is the ability to hold legal rights and duties (October 2020 mark scheme). A natural person is a human being. A juridical (artificial) person is an entity the law treats as a person, such as a limited company. A company can own property, make contracts, sue and be sued in its own name, separately from its shareholders and directors.
Lifting the corporate veil
Because a company is a separate person, its members are normally not personally liable for its debts. Pearson asks students to consider when the courts will pierce the corporate veil and hold the people behind the company, such as directors, responsible. Evaluation: separate personality encourages investment and enterprise, but it can be abused to avoid obligations, which is why the veil can occasionally be lifted.
Worked example
A limited company fails to pay a supplier. Who can the supplier sue?
- The company is a juridical person with its own rights and duties.
- It made the contract and owes the debt.
Answer: The company itself; its shareholders are not normally personally liable, unless the court lifts the corporate veil.
Check yourself
- Legal personality means
- the ability to hold legal rights and duties
- having a criminal record
- the right to vote
- being employed by the state
Show answer
the ability to hold legal rights and duties. This is the definition in Pearson's October 2020 mark scheme.
- Which is a juridical (artificial) legal person?
- A 17 year old student
- A retired judge
- A limited company
- A newborn baby
Show answer
A limited company. A company is an entity the law treats as a person; the others are natural persons.
- Being ordered to pay damages for breaking a contract is an example of
- a liability
- a privilege
- a natural right
- a sanction imposed by a club
Show answer
a liability. Liability is legal responsibility for breach of a duty.
- The protection that stops MPs being sued for defamation over what they say in a parliamentary debate is best described as
- a duty
- a liability
- a sanction
- a privilege
Show answer
a privilege. It is a special legal protection not available to ordinary speakers.
- 'Piercing the corporate veil' means
- registering a new company
- holding the people behind a company personally responsible
- a company suing its customers
- a judge refusing to hear a company case
Show answer
holding the people behind a company personally responsible. The court looks past the company's separate personality to the individuals controlling it.
- Explain one advantage of treating a company as a separate legal person.
Show answer
Shareholders are not personally liable for the company's debts, so people are more willing to invest and start businesses.. Separate personality limits members' risk to what they invested, which encourages investment and enterprise; the company can also own property and contract in its own name.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.