All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)

Public tribunals

Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)

Tribunals decide hundreds of thousands of disputes a year, many between individuals and the state. Specification point 1.2.14 covers their tiers, jurisdiction and panels, and the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Structure (Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007)

The 2007 Act created a two-tier structure:

Panels and procedure

A panel usually has a legally qualified tribunal judge and members with specialist knowledge, such as medicine or accountancy, who have an equal vote. Hearings are less formal than court, often around a table. HMCTS handles almost 800,000 tribunal cases a year (visitor's guide).

Advantages, disadvantages and funding

Advantages (Summer 2021 mark scheme): expert panels; quicker and cheaper than courts; public hearings; less formal.

Disadvantages: little state funding for representation, so cost may still be a barrier; the chair may influence lay members; appeal only on a point of law; publicity.

Fees and access to justice: the Employment Tribunals fees order of 2013 charged £390 for a type A claim and £1,200 for a type B claim. Claims accepted fell by roughly two thirds. In R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor [2017] UKSC 51 the Supreme Court held the fees unlawful because they effectively prevented access to justice, which is inherent in the rule of law; the courts 'do not merely provide a public service like any other'.

Worked example

Under the 2013 order, a type B claim carried a £250 issue fee and a £950 hearing fee. Why did the Supreme Court find such fees unlawful?

  1. Total £1,200 before reaching a hearing.
  2. Claims fell by about two thirds: many could not afford to bring them.
  3. Access to courts and tribunals is inherent in the rule of law.

Answer: The fees effectively prevented access to justice, so the order was unlawful (UNISON, 2017).

Key idea: TCEA 2007: First-tier Tribunal (chambers) and Upper Tribunal (appeals on law, precedent); employment tribunals and EAT separate. Panels: judge plus specialist members. Cheaper, quicker, expert, informal; but limited funding. UNISON (2017): fees blocked access to justice.

Check yourself

  1. Which Act created the First-tier and Upper Tribunals?
    • Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007
    • Constitutional Reform Act 2005
    • Juries Act 1974
    • Courts and Legal Services Act 1990
    Show answer

    Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007. TCEA 2007.

  2. Appeals from the First-tier Tribunal to the Upper Tribunal are on
    • any ground, including fresh facts, as of right
    • sentencing only
    • points of law
    • costs only
    Show answer

    points of law. The Upper Tribunal hears appeals on points of law.

  3. A typical tribunal panel consists of
    • a legally qualified tribunal judge and specialist members
    • twelve jurors
    • three magistrates and a clerk
    • five Supreme Court Justices
    Show answer

    a legally qualified tribunal judge and specialist members. Specialist members bring expertise such as medicine.

  4. Under the 2013 fees order a type A claim had a £160 issue fee and a £230 hearing fee. What was the total, in pounds?
    Show answer

    £390. 160 + 230 = £390.

  5. In R (UNISON) v Lord Chancellor (2017), the Supreme Court held employment tribunal fees unlawful because they
    • were too low to cover costs
    • effectively prevented access to justice
    • had not been approved by the Law Commission
    • were set by the Court of Appeal
    Show answer

    effectively prevented access to justice. Access to justice is inherent in the rule of law.

  6. Appeals from an employment tribunal go first to
    • the First-tier Tribunal
    • the magistrates' court
    • the Crown Court
    • the Employment Appeal Tribunal
    Show answer

    the Employment Appeal Tribunal. Employment tribunals sit outside the two-tier structure.

  7. Give one advantage of tribunals over courts.
    Show answer

    Tribunals are cheaper, quicker and less formal than courts, and the panels include specialist members with expertise in the area.. Advantages: cost, speed, informality, expertise of panel members.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.