All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)
Blackmail: ss21 and 34 Theft Act 1968
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)
A person is guilty of blackmail if, with a view to gain for himself or another or with intent to cause loss to another, he makes any unwarranted demand with menaces (s21(1)). Maximum: 14 years.
Actus reus: demand with menaces
- Demand: may be express or implied (*R v Collister and Warhurst*, 1955). A letter demand is made when posted (*Treacy v DPP*, 1971); the victim need not receive it.
- Menaces: wider than threats of violence (*Thorne v Motor Trade Association*, 1937). Judged objectively: would an ordinary person of normal stability be influenced (*R v Clear*, 1968)? 'Menaces' is a strong word (*R v Harry*, 1974). If the victim is unusually timid and the defendant knows it, menaces may still be found (*R v Garwood*, 1987).
Mens rea: unwarranted, and gain or loss
- Unwarranted (s21(1)): a demand is warranted only if the defendant believes both (a) that he has reasonable grounds for making the demand and (b) that using the menaces is a proper way of reinforcing it. The test is subjective; but a defendant who knows the threatened act is a crime cannot believe it is proper (*R v Harvey*, 1981).
- Gain or loss (s34(2)): in money or other property, temporary or permanent. Gain includes keeping what one has; loss includes not getting what one might get.
Worked example
Problem: Vera, owed 2,000 dollars by a former employer, emails: 'Pay me by Friday or I will tell your wife about your affair.' Is this blackmail?
- Demand: yes, express. Menaces: threatening to reveal an affair could influence an ordinary person (R v Clear).
- View to gain: she wants money (s34).
- Unwarranted? She may believe she has reasonable grounds for demanding a real debt, but does she believe threatening to reveal the affair is a proper means? Most people would not, and the jury decides what she actually believed.
- Conclusion: likely blackmail, unless the jury accepts she genuinely believed this was a proper way to recover the debt.
Answer: Likely blackmail; the issue is her belief about the menaces.
Check yourself
- What is the maximum sentence for blackmail in years?
Show answer
14 years. s21(3): 14 years.
- R v Clear held that whether a threat amounts to menaces is judged
- only by the victim's actual reaction
- by the defendant's opinion
- by whether violence was threatened
- objectively, by the effect on an ordinary person
Show answer
objectively, by the effect on an ordinary person. An objective test, adjusted in Garwood for known timid victims.
- Under R v Harvey, a defendant who threatens to kill unless a debt is paid
- is not guilty if the debt is real
- cannot believe the menace is proper, because he knows it is criminal
- is guilty of robbery instead
- makes a warranted demand
Show answer
cannot believe the menace is proper, because he knows it is criminal. Knowingly threatening a crime cannot be a proper means.
- When is a blackmail demand sent by post made, according to Treacy v DPP?
- When it is opened
- When the victim pays
- When it is posted
- When the police are told
Show answer
When it is posted. The victim need not receive it.
- Which of these is NOT 'gain' or 'loss' for s34(2)?
- Gaining sexual favours
- Keeping money you already have
- Getting a pay rise
- Causing someone to lose a payment they expected
Show answer
Gaining sexual favours. Gain and loss are limited to money or other property.
- When is a demand with menaces 'warranted' under s21(1)?
Show answer
Only if the defendant believes he has reasonable grounds for making the demand and believes that using the menaces is a proper way of reinforcing it.. Two beliefs, both needed.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Theft Act 1968 (revised text)
- e-lawresources: The law of blackmail
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.