All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)
Burglary: s9 Theft Act 1968
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)
Burglary has two forms. Both need entry into a building or part of a building as a trespasser. Maximum: 14 years for a dwelling, 10 years otherwise (s9(3)).
The two offences
| s9(1)(a) | s9(1)(b) | |
|---|---|---|
| Conduct | Enters a building or part of a building as a trespasser | Having entered a building or part as a trespasser |
| Ulterior offence | With intent to steal, inflict grievous bodily harm or do unlawful damage | Steals or attempts to steal, or inflicts or attempts to inflict grievous bodily harm |
| When the intent is needed | At the moment of entry | At the time of the later offence; it can be formed after entry |
| Must the ulterior offence happen? | No: the intent at entry is enough (s9(1)(a)) | Yes: it must be committed or attempted |
Source: Theft Act 1968 s9 (legislation.gov.uk); e-lawresources, The law of burglary
Entry, building, trespasser
- Entry: *R v Collins* (1973) required an 'effective and substantial' entry, but later cases suggest that is no longer needed: partial entry can be enough (*R v Brown*, 1985; *R v Ryan*, 1996).
- Building or part of a building: inhabited vehicles and vessels count (s9(4)). Entering a part of a building where you have no permission, such as behind a shop counter, can be burglary (*R v Walkington*, 1979).
- Trespasser: entering without permission, or going beyond the permission given (*R v Jones and Smith*, 1976).
- Mens rea: the defendant must know, or be reckless as to, the facts making him a trespasser (*R v Collins*), plus the intent for the ulterior offence.
Worked example
Problem: Femi is invited to a party at a house. During the party he goes upstairs into a bedroom marked 'Private' and takes a watch. Has he committed burglary?
- Entry and building: he entered a part of the building (the bedroom), as in R v Walkington.
- Trespasser: his permission covered the party rooms; entering a private bedroom goes beyond it (R v Jones and Smith), and he knew it was private.
- Offence: if he intended to steal when he went in, s9(1)(a); if he decided once inside, s9(1)(b) because he then stole.
- Conclusion: burglary of a dwelling (maximum 14 years), as well as theft of the watch.
Answer: Burglary: part of a building, beyond permission.
Check yourself
- What is the maximum sentence in years for burglary of a dwelling under s9(3)?
Show answer
14 years. 14 years for a dwelling; 10 years otherwise.
- What is the maximum sentence in years for burglary of a building that is not a dwelling?
Show answer
10 years. 10 years.
- A customer walks behind a shop counter into an area for staff only, intending to take money from the till. Following R v Walkington, this is
- not burglary because the shop was open
- only theft
- entry into part of a building as a trespasser
- not entry because he did not break in
Show answer
entry into part of a building as a trespasser. Part of a building where he had no permission.
- R v Jones and Smith shows that a person can be a trespasser when
- they have the owner's general permission and use it properly
- they go beyond the permission they were given
- they enter through an open door
- they live in the building
Show answer
they go beyond the permission they were given. Exceeding permission makes the entry trespassory.
- Following R v Brown and R v Ryan, a defendant who leans through a window with only his upper body inside
- has not entered until fully inside
- must have caused damage to enter
- has entered only if he took something
- can have entered, because entry need not be substantial
Show answer
can have entered, because entry need not be substantial. Partial entry can be enough.
- Gita enters a house as a trespasser to shelter from rain, then decides to steal a phone and takes it. Which offence?
- s9(1)(a), because she entered as a trespasser
- s9(1)(b), because she stole after entering as a trespasser
- No burglary, because she had no intent at entry
- Robbery
Show answer
s9(1)(b), because she stole after entering as a trespasser. Intent formed after entry: s9(1)(b).
- Explain the main difference between s9(1)(a) and s9(1)(b) burglary.
Show answer
Under s9(1)(a) the intent to steal, inflict GBH or do damage must exist at the time of entry, but the offence need not be carried out; under s9(1)(b) the defendant, having entered as a trespasser, actually steals or inflicts GBH or attempts to.. Timing of intent and whether the offence happens.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Theft Act 1968 (revised text)
- e-lawresources: The law of burglary
- Pearson Edexcel IAL Law sample assessment materials, Issue 1, February 2015 (Paper 2: The Law in Action)
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.