All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.3)
Consumer Rights Act 2015: goods
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.3)
When a trader sells goods to a consumer, the Consumer Rights Act 2015 implies terms into the contract and gives the consumer a ladder of remedies.
Who is protected
A trader acts for business purposes; a consumer is an individual acting wholly or mainly outside their trade or business (s2). The trader must prove someone is not a consumer.
The implied terms
- s9 Satisfactory quality: the standard a reasonable person would expect, taking account of description, price and other circumstances. Quality includes fitness for usual purposes, appearance and finish, freedom from minor defects, safety and durability. Defects pointed out before the contract, or that an examination should have revealed, do not count.
- s10 Fit for a particular purpose made known to the trader, where the consumer relies on the trader's skill or judgement.
- s11 As described (and matching any sample).
Under s31 these terms cannot be excluded.
The remedies ladder
| Tier | Remedy | Section | Key rules |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Short-term right to reject | s20, s22 | Full refund; must be used within 30 days |
| 2 | Repair or replacement | s23 | Within a reasonable time, without significant inconvenience, at the trader's cost |
| 3 | Price reduction or final right to reject | s24 | After one failed repair or replacement, or if repair and replacement are impossible or not done in time. No deduction for use in the first 6 months (except motor vehicles) |
Source: Consumer Rights Act 2015 ss19 to 24, legislation.gov.uk
Proof and other remedies
If a fault appears within 6 months of delivery, it is presumed to have been there at delivery unless the trader proves otherwise (s19). The consumer can also claim damages for other loss.
Worked example
Problem: Maya buys a new washing machine from a shop for 600 dollars. Five weeks later it floods the kitchen because of a faulty seal. What can she claim?
- Issue: breach of s9 satisfactory quality (safety and durability).
- Rule: the short-term right to reject lasts 30 days (s22), so it has gone. She can require repair or replacement (s23).
- Apply: the fault appeared within 6 months, so it is presumed present at delivery (s19).
- Conclusion: she should ask for repair or replacement; if that fails, she can have a price reduction or use the final right to reject (s24), with no deduction for use in the first 6 months. Damages may cover the flood damage.
Answer: Repair or replacement first, then s24 remedies; damages for consequential loss.
Check yourself
- How many days does a consumer normally have to use the short-term right to reject under CRA 2015 s22?
Show answer
30 days. The short-term right to reject lasts 30 days.
- Within how many months of delivery is a fault presumed to have been present at delivery?
Show answer
6 months. s19 presumption: six months.
- A consumer paid 600 dollars for a sofa with a defect. The court finds a 25% price reduction appropriate under s24. How many dollars should be refunded?
Show answer
150 dollars. 600 x 0.25 = 150 dollars.
- A customer tells a paint shop she needs paint for a bathroom; the shop recommends a paint that peels in the steam. Which implied term is broken?
- s10 fitness for a particular purpose
- s11 as described
- s49 reasonable care and skill
- s52 reasonable time
Show answer
s10 fitness for a particular purpose. She made the purpose known and relied on the shop's skill.
- Which defect would NOT breach s9 satisfactory quality?
- A dent hidden inside the packaging
- A phone that stops charging after a week
- A scratch the shop pointed out before the sale
- A kettle that gives electric shocks
Show answer
A scratch the shop pointed out before the sale. Defects drawn to the consumer's attention before the contract do not count.
- When does the final right to reject under s24 become available?
- After one repair or replacement has failed to fix the goods
- On the day of purchase
- Only after 6 months
- Whenever the consumer changes their mind
Show answer
After one repair or replacement has failed to fix the goods. s24 is the third tier, after repair or replacement.
- What does 'satisfactory quality' mean under CRA 2015 s9?
Show answer
Goods meet the standard a reasonable person would consider satisfactory, taking account of the description, the price and all other circumstances.. The objective test in s9(2).
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 1 (goods)
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.