All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.2)
Exclusion clauses: incorporation, UCTA 1977 and the CRA 2015
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.2)
An exclusion clause tries to exclude or limit one party's liability. It is effective only if it is part of the contract, covers the loss, and survives statutory control.
Step 1: incorporation
- Signature: a signed document binds the signer even if unread (*L'Estrange v Graucob*, 1934), unless the effect was misrepresented (*Curtis v Chemical Cleaning*, 1951).
- Reasonable notice before or at the time of contracting (*Parker v South Eastern Railway*, 1877). Notice given afterwards is too late (*Olley v Marlborough Court*, 1949). Onerous terms need more prominent notice (*J Spurling v Bradshaw*, 1956: the 'red hand' remark).
- Course of dealing: consistent previous dealings on the same terms (*Spurling v Bradshaw*; *McCutcheon v David MacBrayne*, 1964).
Step 2 is construction: the clause must cover the loss, read on its natural meaning.
Step 3: business contracts, UCTA 1977
UCTA applies to business liability between businesses (consumer contracts moved to the CRA 2015):
- s2(1): liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence cannot be excluded or restricted.
- s2(2): other loss from negligence can be excluded only if the term is reasonable.
- s3: where one party deals on the other's written standard terms, exclusion of liability for breach must be reasonable.
- s11: reasonableness is judged at the time the contract was made; for a cap on liability the court considers resources and insurance; the party relying on the clause must prove it is reasonable.
Consumer contracts, CRA 2015
- s31: a trader cannot exclude or restrict liability for the goods implied terms (ss9 to 17).
- s57: a trader cannot exclude liability for reasonable care and skill in services (s49), or restrict it below the price paid.
- s62: an unfair term is not binding on the consumer. A term is unfair if, contrary to good faith, it causes a significant imbalance in rights and obligations to the consumer's detriment.
- s65: a trader cannot exclude or restrict liability for death or personal injury caused by negligence.
Worked example
Problem: A dry cleaner's ticket, handed over after payment, says 'No liability for any damage however caused'. A consumer's coat is ruined by careless cleaning. Can the cleaner rely on the clause?
- Incorporation: notice came after the contract was made, so the clause is probably not incorporated (Olley v Marlborough Court).
- Statute: even if incorporated, CRA s57 stops a trader excluding liability for failing to use reasonable care and skill (s49).
- Fairness: a clause excluding all liability is likely unfair under s62.
- Conclusion: the cleaner cannot rely on it; the consumer can claim repeat performance, price reduction or damages.
Answer: No: late notice, and CRA ss57 and 62.
Check yourself
- L'Estrange v Graucob shows that an exclusion clause in a signed document
- binds the signer even if they did not read it
- binds only if read aloud
- never binds a consumer
- binds only if printed in red
Show answer
binds the signer even if they did not read it. Signature incorporates the terms, unless misrepresented (Curtis).
- In Olley v Marlborough Court a notice in a hotel bedroom did not protect the hotel because
- it was not signed by a director
- hotels cannot exclude liability
- the contract was made at reception before the notice was seen
- the guest was a minor
Show answer
the contract was made at reception before the notice was seen. Notice must be given before or at the time of contracting.
- Between two businesses, a clause excluding liability for personal injury caused by negligence is
- void under UCTA s2(1)
- valid if reasonable under s11
- valid if signed
- valid if the injured party was warned
Show answer
void under UCTA s2(1). Death or personal injury from negligence cannot be excluded.
- Under UCTA s11(5), who must prove a clause is reasonable?
- The party challenging the clause
- The court
- The Consumer Rights Commission
- The party relying on the clause
Show answer
The party relying on the clause. The burden is on the party claiming the clause is reasonable.
- Under CRA 2015 s62, a consumer contract term is unfair if
- it is in small print
- contrary to good faith, it causes a significant imbalance to the consumer's detriment
- the trader made a loss
- it was individually negotiated
Show answer
contrary to good faith, it causes a significant imbalance to the consumer's detriment. That is the fairness test in s62(4).
- Name two ways an exclusion clause can be incorporated into a contract.
Show answer
By signature, or by reasonable notice given before or at the time of the contract (or by a consistent course of dealing).. Signature, notice, course of dealing.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- Digestible Notes: Exclusion clauses
- legislation.gov.uk: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977
- legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 1 (goods)
- legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 1 Chapter 4 (services, ss 49 to 57)
- legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 2 (unfair terms, ss 61 to 68)
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.