All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.6)
Negligence: damage, causation, remoteness and damages
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.6)
The claimant must prove that the breach caused damage of a kind the law recognises, and that the damage was not too remote. Damages then aim to put the claimant back in the position before the tort.
Factual causation
The but for test: would the harm have happened but for the defendant's breach? *Barnett v Chelsea and Kensington Hospital* (1969) is the leading authority: if the harm would have happened even without the breach, the defendant is not liable. An intervening act (novus actus interveniens) by a third party or the claimant may break the chain.
Legal causation: remoteness
- *The Wagon Mound (No 1)* (1961) replaced the direct consequence test of *Re Polemis* (1921): the damage must be of a kind that was reasonably foreseeable.
- If the kind of harm was foreseeable, it need not have happened in a foreseeable way: *Hughes v Lord Advocate* (1963). Pearson's mark scheme pairs it with *Doughty v Turner Manufacturing* (1964) and *Bradford v Robinson Rentals* on kind or method of damage.
- Thin skull (egg shell) rule: take your victim as you find them, so the full extent of harm is recoverable even if the claimant was unusually vulnerable (*Smith v Leech Brain*, 1962; *Page v Smith*, 1995).
Damage and damages
Recoverable damage includes personal injury and damage to property. Compensatory damages:
- Special damages: losses that can be calculated, such as lost earnings to trial, medical bills and repair costs.
- General damages: pain, suffering and loss of amenity, and future loss of earnings.
- The claimant must take reasonable steps to mitigate loss.
- Damages may be reduced for contributory negligence (next lesson).
Worked example
Problem: A window cleaner carelessly leaves his ladder lying across a narrow shop doorway. Farah, leaving the shop, trips over it. The antique vase she has just bought is smashed, and her broken ankle takes far longer than usual to heal because of a rare bone condition. Is the window cleaner liable for all of this?
- Factual causation: but for the ladder across the doorway, Farah would not have fallen (Barnett).
- Remoteness: injury from tripping over an obstruction is a foreseeable kind of harm (Wagon Mound), so the injury is recoverable.
- Thin skull: the longer recovery because of her condition is recoverable (Smith v Leech Brain).
- Vase: damage to things a person is carrying is a foreseeable kind of harm from a fall; only the kind of harm must be foreseeable, not its extent or value. Conclusion: liable for both, subject to Farah mitigating her loss.
Answer: Liable for the injury (including the thin skull extent) and the vase.
Check yourself
- A doctor negligently fails to examine a patient, who dies of a condition that could not have been treated in time anyway. Applying Barnett, the doctor is
- liable, because a duty was breached
- not liable, because the breach fails the but for test
- liable under res ipsa loquitur
- not liable, because doctors owe no duty
Show answer
not liable, because the breach fails the but for test. Death would have occurred anyway.
- The Wagon Mound (No 1) test for remoteness is that the damage must be
- a direct consequence of the breach
- intended by the defendant
- of the exact extent foreseen
- of a kind that was reasonably foreseeable
Show answer
of a kind that was reasonably foreseeable. It replaced Re Polemis.
- Hughes v Lord Advocate shows that
- the exact method of harm must be foreseen
- damage of a foreseeable kind is recoverable even if it happened in an unforeseeable way
- only property damage is recoverable
- the claimant must foresee the harm
Show answer
damage of a foreseeable kind is recoverable even if it happened in an unforeseeable way. Kind of harm matters, not the precise method.
- A careless cyclist knocks over a pedestrian, who suffers unusually serious injury because of a rare bone condition. In negligence the cyclist is
- liable only for a normal person's injury
- not liable because the injury was unforeseeable
- liable for the full injury under the thin skull rule
- liable only if they knew of the condition
Show answer
liable for the full injury under the thin skull rule. Take your victim as you find them (Smith v Leech Brain).
- A claimant's special damages are 12500 dollars and general damages are 27500 dollars. What is the total award before any reduction?
Show answer
40000 dollars. 12500 + 27500 = 40000.
- Distinguish special damages from general damages in a personal injury claim.
Show answer
Special damages are calculable losses such as lost earnings and medical costs up to trial; general damages compensate for pain, suffering and loss of amenity, which cannot be precisely calculated.. Two heads of compensatory damages.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Negligence overview (factual causation)
- e-lawresources: Remoteness of damage
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.