All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.6)
Negligence: breach of duty and res ipsa loquitur
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.6)
Breach asks whether the defendant fell below the standard of the reasonable person. The test is objective, but the court adjusts it for some defendants and weighs risk factors.
The standard
- Objective: the reasonable person (*Vaughan v Menlove*, 1837).
- Learners are judged as competent qualified people: a learner driver against a reasonably competent driver (*Nettleship v Weston*, 1971).
- Children are judged against a reasonable child of the same age (*Mullin v Richards*, 1998).
- Professionals against a reasonably competent member of the profession: not negligent if acting in accordance with a practice accepted by a responsible body of opinion (*Bolam v Friern HMC*, 1957), provided that opinion is logically defensible (*Bolitho*, 1997).
Risk factors
| Factor | Effect | Case |
|---|---|---|
| Probability of harm | The less likely the harm, the fewer precautions needed; no need to guard against the unforeseeable (Roe v Minister of Health, 1954) | Bolton v Stone (1951); Haley v London Electricity Board (1965) |
| Seriousness of harm | Greater precautions where the harm would be serious | Paris v Stepney BC (1951); The Wagon Mound (No 2) (1967) |
| Cost of precautions | No need for precautions out of all proportion to the risk | Latimer v AEC (1953) |
| Social utility | A risk may be justified by an important purpose, such as an emergency service | Watt v Hertfordshire CC (1954) |
Source: e-lawresources, Breach of duty; Pearson June 2025 examiner report (Haley, Watt)
Res ipsa loquitur
'The thing speaks for itself.' Where the thing that caused the harm was under the defendant's management and the accident would not ordinarily happen if proper care were used, the accident is itself evidence of negligence unless the defendant explains it (*Scott v London and St Katherine Docks*, 1865, per Erle CJ). It helps a claimant who cannot show exactly what went wrong.
Worked example
Problem: Ali, a learner driver on her first lesson, mounts the pavement and injures a pedestrian. Her lawyer argues she did her best. Is she in breach?
- Issue: what standard applies to a learner?
- Rule: learners are judged by the standard of a reasonably competent qualified driver (Nettleship v Weston).
- Apply: a competent driver would not mount the pavement; her inexperience does not lower the standard.
- Conclusion: she is in breach. Evaluation: the rule seems harsh but protects victims and reflects compulsory insurance.
Answer: Breach: Nettleship v Weston.
Check yourself
- A learner driver is judged by the standard of
- a reasonable learner
- the best driver in the country
- their own ability
- a reasonably competent qualified driver
Show answer
a reasonably competent qualified driver. Nettleship v Weston.
- Bolton v Stone is cited for which breach factor?
- The cost of precautions
- The probability of harm
- Social utility
- The standard for children
Show answer
The probability of harm. A very small risk may not require further precautions.
- An employer knows one worker already has a serious eye condition. Following Paris v Stepney BC, the employer should
- take the same precautions as for everyone
- take no precautions because he owes no duty
- apply the Bolam test
- take greater precautions because the harm to that worker would be more serious
Show answer
take greater precautions because the harm to that worker would be more serious. Seriousness of harm raises the precautions required.
- Under Bolam, a doctor is not negligent if
- they acted in accordance with a practice accepted by a responsible body of medical opinion
- the patient recovers
- they followed their own instincts
- they were a trainee
Show answer
they acted in accordance with a practice accepted by a responsible body of medical opinion. Bolitho adds that the opinion must be logically defensible.
- Watt v Hertfordshire CC is cited for which breach factor?
- Probability of harm
- The learner standard
- Social utility of the defendant's activity
- Res ipsa loquitur
Show answer
Social utility of the defendant's activity. An important purpose, such as an emergency response, can justify a risk.
- When does res ipsa loquitur apply?
Show answer
When the thing causing harm was under the defendant's control and the accident would not normally happen without negligence, so the facts themselves suggest a lack of care.. Scott v London and St Katherine Docks.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Breach of duty
- swarb: Scott v London and St Katherine Docks Co (1865)
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.