All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.6)

Negligence: duty of care

Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.6)

Negligence is the main alternative to a contract claim: it protects people who have no contract with the defendant. The claimant must prove duty, breach and damage. Duty comes first.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

From neighbour principle to Caparo

Robinson (2018): the current approach

In *Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire* (Supreme Court, 8 February 2018) police officers arresting a suspect knocked over an elderly passer-by. The Court held:

The June 2025 examiner report criticised answers that used Caparo as the general test: use Robinson for established duties, and Caparo for novel situations.

Policy and the limits of duty

Courts may refuse a duty for policy reasons, such as the risk of defensive practices or of flooding the courts. Pearson's Summer 2021 mark scheme cites *Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire* (1989) for public policy meaning no duty, *Home Office v Dorset Yacht* (1970) for reasonable foresight supporting a duty, and *Caparo* for legal proximity. *Bourhill v Young* (1943) is the usual authority on proximity, and the June 2025 report pointed to it on proximity for a claimant who was not directly involved in the accident.

Worked example

Problem: A courier on an electric bike swerves carelessly onto the pavement and hits Aiko, who is waiting at a bus stop. Does the courier owe Aiko a duty of care?

  1. Issue: duty of care (only the contentious element needs depth).
  2. Rule: road users owe other road users and pedestrians a duty; this is an established category, so following Robinson there is no need to apply the full Caparo test.
  3. Apply: physical injury to a pedestrian from careless riding is plainly foreseeable and within the established category.
  4. Conclusion: a duty is owed; the answer should then move on to breach and damage.

Answer: Yes: an established duty, so Robinson applies without a Caparo analysis.

Key idea: Duty: neighbour principle (Donoghue v Stevenson). For established categories, duty follows precedent (Robinson 2018). For novel situations, use Caparo: foreseeability, proximity, fair just and reasonable, developed incrementally.

Check yourself

  1. According to Robinson (2018), when is the 'fair, just and reasonable' stage of Caparo needed?
    • In every negligence claim
    • Only in contract claims
    • Only in novel situations not covered by established principles
    • Never, because Caparo was overruled
    Show answer

    Only in novel situations not covered by established principles. Robinson rejected a universal three-stage test.

  2. Lord Atkin's neighbour principle comes from
    • Donoghue v Stevenson
    • Caparo v Dickman
    • Bolton v Stone
    • Nettleship v Weston
    Show answer

    Donoghue v Stevenson. House of Lords, 1932.

  3. Which is NOT one of the three Caparo stages?
    • Reasonable foreseeability of harm
    • Proximity
    • The defendant intended the harm
    • Fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty
    Show answer

    The defendant intended the harm. Intention is not required in negligence.

  4. Why did the police owe a duty in Robinson?
    • Police always owe a duty to protect everyone from criminals
    • The officers' positive act created a foreseeable risk of injury to a bystander
    • The claimant had a contract with the police
    • The claimant was a police officer
    Show answer

    The officers' positive act created a foreseeable risk of injury to a bystander. A positive act, not an omission to protect.

  5. Pearson's mark scheme cites Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire as an example of
    • a duty owed because of proximity
    • res ipsa loquitur
    • the thin skull rule
    • no duty of care for reasons of public policy
    Show answer

    no duty of care for reasons of public policy. Public policy meant no duty was owed.

  6. The June 2025 examiner report says weaker answers applied every element of negligence when only duty was in issue. What should you do instead?
    Show answer

    Deal briefly with the settled elements and focus the analysis on the contentious element, here duty of care.. Think like a legal adviser.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.