All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.3, 2.3.4)
The European Court of Human Rights: procedure and the effect of judgments on the UK
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.3, 2.3.4)
When domestic remedies fail, an individual can take a case against the UK to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg. Its judgments bind the UK, but how the government responds is a political matter.
The Court and how to apply
- An international court in Strasbourg, with one judge per state that has ratified the Convention. Judges sit as individuals.
- Who: individuals, groups and organisations personally and directly affected by a violation attributable to a public authority of a Convention state (Article 34). It does not hear complaints against private parties.
- Admissibility: the applicant must first exhaust all domestic remedies and apply within four months of the final domestic decision (Article 35(1) as amended by Protocol No. 15; the four-month limit applies to final decisions from 1 February 2022, replacing the old six months). Applications are made in writing and the procedure is free.
- Stages: admissibility; then a friendly settlement is encouraged; if none, the Court decides whether there was a violation.
- Remedies: a declaration of violation and just satisfaction (compensation and costs) under Article 41.
Effect of a successful appeal on the government
- Article 46: the UK undertakes to abide by final judgments; the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe supervises execution. The Court cannot itself enforce its judgments.
- Typical responses: changing the law (Pearson's mark scheme gives *Dudgeon v UK* (1981), after which homosexual acts were decriminalised in Northern Ireland), a remedial order under s10 HRA, or a compromise.
- *Hirst v UK (No 2)* (Grand Chamber, 2005) held the UK's blanket ban on prisoners voting was a 'general, automatic and indiscriminate restriction' on a Convention right. In February 2011 MPs backed a non-binding motion opposing change by 234 votes to 22, and implementation was delayed for years; Pearson's mark scheme describes the eventual response as a compromise giving limited voting rights.
- In the individual case the applicant receives just satisfaction; the wider effect is pressure to change law and practice so similar cases do not arise.
Worked example
Problem: Ana's complaint that the UK breached her Article 8 rights fails in the Supreme Court. What must she do to take the case to Strasbourg, and what happens if she wins?
- Admissibility: she has exhausted domestic remedies (the Supreme Court is the final court); she must apply within four months of that decision, showing she was personally and directly affected.
- Procedure: the Court checks admissibility, invites a friendly settlement, then decides the merits.
- If she wins: a finding of violation and possibly just satisfaction (Article 41).
- Effect on the government: under Article 46 the UK must abide by the judgment, supervised by the Committee of Ministers; it may amend the law (as after Dudgeon), use a s10 remedial order, or, as with Hirst, respond slowly and by compromise.
Answer: Exhaust remedies, apply within four months; binding judgment, political implementation.
Check yourself
- Within how many months of the final domestic decision must an application to the ECtHR now be made?
Show answer
4 months. Four months (Protocol 15 reduced it from six).
- In the February 2011 Commons vote on prisoner voting, 234 MPs supported the motion opposing change and 22 opposed it. What was the majority?
Show answer
212 votes. 234 - 22 = 212.
- Before applying to Strasbourg, an applicant must
- exhaust all domestic remedies
- obtain permission from the UK government
- pay a court fee
- be a citizen of a Convention state
Show answer
exhaust all domestic remedies. Article 35(1).
- Who supervises whether a state complies with a judgment of the European Court of Human Rights?
- The UK Supreme Court
- The European Union
- The judge who decided the case
- The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe
Show answer
The Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe. Article 46.
- What did the Grand Chamber decide in Hirst v UK (No 2) (2005)?
- Prisoners have no right to vote under the Convention
- The blanket ban on prisoners voting breached the Convention
- The UK must release all prisoners
- The case was inadmissible
Show answer
The blanket ban on prisoners voting breached the Convention. A 'general, automatic and indiscriminate restriction'.
- What is 'just satisfaction' under Article 41?
- An order quashing a UK statute
- A criminal penalty on government ministers
- A friendly settlement
- Compensation the Court may award to the injured party
Show answer
Compensation the Court may award to the injured party. Money for certain damage, and costs.
- Give two ways the UK government may have to respond when the European Court of Human Rights finds that the UK has violated the Convention.
Show answer
It must abide by the judgment under Article 46, so it may change the law by Act of Parliament or a remedial order, and pay just satisfaction to the applicant; the Committee of Ministers supervises compliance.. Article 46 makes the judgment binding; the response is political.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- European Court of Human Rights: Questions and answers
- Council of Europe: Time limit for ECHR applications reduced to four months (from 1 February 2022, Protocol No. 15)
- Council of Europe: European Convention on Human Rights (text)
- UK Human Rights Blog: Prisoner votes (10 February 2011)
- legislation.gov.uk: Human Rights Act 1998
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.