All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.2)
Human Rights Act 1998: Articles 10 and 11
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.2)
The Human Rights Act 1998 brings the European Convention on Human Rights into UK law. The specification focuses on freedom of expression (Article 10) and freedom of assembly and association (Article 11).
How the HRA works
- s1: the Convention rights include Articles 2 to 12 and 14.
- s2: courts must take into account Strasbourg case law.
- s3: legislation must be read and given effect compatibly with Convention rights so far as it is possible to do so.
- s4: if that is impossible, the higher courts may make a declaration of incompatibility; the Act stays valid and the parties are not bound.
- s6: it is unlawful for a public authority (including courts) to act incompatibly with a Convention right; Parliament is not a public authority.
- s7: a victim can bring proceedings, normally within one year.
- s8: the court may grant any just and appropriate remedy; damages only if necessary for just satisfaction.
- s10: a minister can make a remedial order to amend incompatible legislation.
- s12: before restraining publication, courts must give particular regard to freedom of expression.
- s19: a minister must make a statement of compatibility for every Bill.
Articles 10 and 11
| Article 10: freedom of expression | Article 11: freedom of assembly and association | |
|---|---|---|
| The right | To hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority | To peaceful assembly and to freedom of association, including forming and joining trade unions |
| Restrictions allowed if | Prescribed by law and necessary in a democratic society | Prescribed by law and necessary in a democratic society |
| Legitimate aims include | National security, public safety, prevention of disorder or crime, health or morals, the reputation or rights of others, confidential information, authority of the judiciary | National security, public safety, prevention of disorder or crime, health or morals, rights and freedoms of others; lawful limits on armed forces, police and administration |
Source: European Convention on Human Rights (Council of Europe text)
Applying a qualified right
Use three questions for any restriction on Articles 8, 10 or 11:
1. Is it prescribed by law (a clear legal basis)?
2. Does it pursue a legitimate aim listed in paragraph 2?
3. Is it necessary in a democratic society, meaning proportionate: no more than needed to meet the aim?
Only peaceful assembly is protected by Article 11. The June 2025 examiner report stressed that answers must apply Article 11 to the facts and deal with the restriction exception.
Worked example
Problem: Chidi organises a silent candlelit vigil in a town square to protest about a factory closure. The council, using a bylaw, bans all gatherings in the square for six months because the vigil might leave litter. Has Article 11 been restricted, and is the restriction lawful?
- Right: a peaceful assembly is protected by Article 11.
- Restriction: a six-month ban is an interference by a public authority (s6 HRA).
- Justification: prescribed by law (the bylaw); legitimate aim (perhaps the rights of others); but is a long blanket ban necessary and proportionate when litter could be dealt with by conditions or clearing up afterwards?
- Conclusion: probably disproportionate; Chidi, as a victim (s7), could challenge it and seek a remedy under s8.
Answer: Interference likely disproportionate.
Check yourself
- Under s3 HRA 1998, courts must
- strike down Acts of Parliament that breach Convention rights
- read legislation compatibly with Convention rights so far as it is possible
- follow every Strasbourg judgment as binding precedent
- ask Parliament before deciding a human rights case
Show answer
read legislation compatibly with Convention rights so far as it is possible. Interpretive obligation.
- What is the effect of a declaration of incompatibility under s4?
- The Act is immediately void
- The claimant wins damages automatically
- The Act is suspended for a year
- The Act remains valid and enforceable; it is for Parliament or a minister to change it
Show answer
The Act remains valid and enforceable; it is for Parliament or a minister to change it. Parliamentary sovereignty is preserved.
- Which body is NOT a 'public authority' under s6 HRA?
- A court
- Parliament
- A police force
- A local council
Show answer
Parliament. s6(3) excludes Parliament.
- A restriction on Article 10 is lawful only if it is prescribed by law, pursues a legitimate aim and is
- supported by a majority of voters
- approved by the European Court in advance
- necessary in a democratic society
- contained in a contract
Show answer
necessary in a democratic society. Necessity, meaning proportionality.
- Which assembly is protected by Article 11?
- Peaceful assembly
- Any assembly, including violent riots
- Only assemblies approved in writing by the police
- Only trade union meetings
Show answer
Peaceful assembly. Article 11 protects peaceful assembly.
- Within how many years must a standalone claim under s7 HRA normally be brought?
Show answer
1 years. One year, or longer if the court considers it fair.
- Name two legitimate aims for restricting freedom of expression under Article 10(2).
Show answer
National security and the protection of the reputation or rights of others (others include public safety and prevention of disorder or crime).. Paragraph 2 lists the aims.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Human Rights Act 1998
- Council of Europe: European Convention on Human Rights (text)
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.