All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, technique)

Assess and Evaluate questions: levels and how to reach the top band

Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, technique)

The 6-, 10-, 14- and 20-mark questions are marked by levels. Knowing what each level rewards tells you how to write: accurate law with authority, developed reasoning, competing arguments and a justified conclusion.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

The level descriptors (Summer 2021 mark scheme, paraphrased)

Level10 marks14 marks20 marksWhat it looks like
11 to 21 to 31 to 4Isolated knowledge; application weakly related to the scenario; little authority
23 to 44 to 65 to 8Some knowledge applied; incomplete or inaccurate reasoning; authorities may be misapplied; outcomes attempted
35 to 67 to 109 to 14Accurate knowledge supported by authority; logical but possibly unbalanced reasoning; competing arguments contrasted
47 to 1011 to 1415 to 20Accurate, thorough knowledge supported throughout by authority; well-developed reasoning; full awareness of competing arguments; balanced comparison; effective, justified conclusions

Source: Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021

Assessment objectives in the long questions

In the Summer 2021 paper a 14-mark Evaluate question was split AO1 2, AO2 2, AO3 4, AO4 6, and the 20-mark question AO1 2, AO2 2, AO3 8, AO4 8. So only a small share of marks is for knowledge: most reward analysis (how the law would resolve the dispute) and evaluation (weighing arguments and concluding).

How to move from Level 3 to Level 4

Worked example

Turn this Level 3 sentence into Level 4: 'Hamid took the champagne, so he appropriated it and is guilty of theft (R v Morris).'

  1. Add the competing argument: Hamid says he was so drunk he did not know what he was doing, which goes to intention to permanently deprive and dishonesty, both specific intent elements (Beard).
  2. Weigh it: a drunken intent is still an intent (Sheehan and Moore); he hid the bottles in his bag, which suggests he knew what he was doing.
  3. Identify evidence: CCTV or witnesses on his state would matter.
  4. Conclude: 'On balance, the jury is likely to find he formed the intent, so he is likely to be convicted of theft, and intoxication will not help.'

Answer: Argument, counter-argument, weighing, evidence, justified conclusion.

Key idea: Levels reward accurate law with authority (Level 3) plus well-developed reasoning, full awareness of competing arguments and justified conclusions (Level 4). Most long-question marks are AO3 and AO4, so weigh both sides, judge which is stronger, and conclude.

Check yourself

  1. On a 14-mark question, what is the lowest mark in Level 4?
    Show answer

    11 marks. Level 4 is 11 to 14.

  2. On the 20-mark question, what is the lowest mark in Level 4?
    Show answer

    15 marks. Level 4 is 15 to 20.

  3. In the Summer 2021 20-mark question the AO split was AO1 2, AO2 2, AO3 8, AO4 8. How many marks were for AO3 and AO4 together?
    Show answer

    16 marks. 8 + 8 = 16 of 20.

  4. Which feature distinguishes Level 4 from Level 3 in the Paper 2 descriptors?
    • Using at least one case
    • Accurate knowledge
    • Full awareness of competing arguments with effective, justified conclusions
    • Mentioning the scenario
    Show answer

    Full awareness of competing arguments with effective, justified conclusions. Level 3 already needs accurate knowledge with authority.

  5. According to the June 2025 report, which feature is typical of a Level 3 rather than a Level 4 answer?
    • Asserting conclusions without evaluating the evidence
    • Using headings
    • Using the vertical approach
    • Citing Robinson
    Show answer

    Asserting conclusions without evaluating the evidence. The report described assertions without weighing as a Level 3 feature; Level 4 weighs the arguments.

  6. How can you raise an Evaluate answer from Level 3 to Level 4?
    Show answer

    By weighing the arguments for and against each contentious point with authority, explaining which is stronger and why, and reaching a justified conclusion on liability and remedies.. Competing arguments plus justified conclusions.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.