All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, technique)
Problem questions: IRAC, structure and worked answers
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, technique)
Most Paper 2 marks come from applying law to a scenario. A clear method, Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion (IRAC), stops you retelling the story and keeps every sentence earning marks.
IRAC, element by element
- Issue: name the precise legal question (for example, 'Was Callum's leaving the restaurant without paying a making off?').
- Rule: state the law with authority: the statutory section and one well-chosen case. Use cases for their principle, not their story.
- Application: link each element of the rule to specific facts, and say where the facts support or undermine it. This is where most marks are.
- Conclusion: give the likely outcome for that element, then for the party overall.
The June 2025 examiner report did not use the label IRAC, but described the same steps, and said both a vertical approach (law then application for each element in turn) and a horizontal approach (all the law, then all the application) can reach full marks.
What the examiners want
From the June 2025 report:
- Pick the right offence or claim first (for example making off without payment, not theft or fraud, for leaving without paying).
- Spend time on the contentious elements; deal with settled ones in a line.
- Use headings for each party or claim where several people are involved.
- Use the correct, current authority: Robinson for established duties of care; Barton and Booth for dishonesty. Outdated authorities lose credit.
- Think like a legal adviser: give the client only what is relevant.
- Cover remedies when the question asks for 'rights and remedies'.
A model paragraph
Scenario: 'Kai pushes Leo in a bar; Leo falls and breaks his wrist.'
Issue: whether Kai is liable under s20 OAPA 1861. Rule: s20 requires unlawful wounding or inflicting grievous bodily harm, with intention or foresight that some harm might result (*Savage; DPP v Parmenter*). Application: a broken wrist is arguably really serious harm, taking account of Leo's circumstances (*Bollom*); pushing someone in a crowded bar makes it likely Kai foresaw some harm, though he may say he meant only to annoy. Conclusion: Kai is likely liable under s20; if foresight is not proved, he is liable under s47, which needs only intention or recklessness as to the battery.
Worked example
Plan a 20-mark answer: 'Sofia is cycling when Marek, a van driver checking his phone, opens his door into her path. Sofia's friend Abi, cycling some way behind, sees the crash and suffers shock. Evaluate Sofia's and Abi's rights and remedies in negligence.'
- Heading 1, Sofia v Marek. Duty: established road-user duty, Robinson, so no full Caparo analysis. Breach: opening a door while on the phone falls below the reasonable driver standard; one line. Causation: but for (Barnett); injury of a foreseeable kind (Wagon Mound). Defences: was Sofia careless, for example not wearing a helmet, and did that add to her injuries (Capps v Miller, 1945 Act)?
- Heading 2, Abi: any claim is about a duty to a person who only witnesses harm; the June 2025 report pointed to Bourhill v Young on proximity in a similar situation. Identify this as the contentious issue and weigh it.
- Remedies: special and general damages; reduction for contributory negligence; mitigation.
- Conclusion: Sofia very likely succeeds, possibly with a reduction; Abi's claim is weaker because proximity is doubtful. Give a reasoned judgement, not just a summary.
Answer: Headings per party, IRAC per element, depth on contentious points, remedies, justified conclusion.
Check yourself
- In IRAC, where are most marks usually earned on Paper 2?
- Restating the facts of the scenario
- Listing as many cases as possible
- Writing a long introduction
- Application of the rule to the facts
Show answer
Application of the rule to the facts. AO2 and AO3 reward linking law to facts and analysing outcomes.
- According to the June 2025 report, which structure can achieve full marks?
- Only a horizontal approach
- Either a vertical or a horizontal approach
- Only a vertical approach
- Only bullet points
Show answer
Either a vertical or a horizontal approach. Both can work if law and application are linked.
- How should cases be used in a problem answer?
- By retelling the full facts of each case
- Only in the conclusion
- As a replacement for applying the law
- As authority for a legal principle, briefly linked to the facts
Show answer
As authority for a legal principle, briefly linked to the facts. The report praised using cases as references to principles.
- A scenario has a diner slipping out of a restaurant without paying, intending never to pay. Which mistake did the June 2025 report warn against on a similar question?
- Analysing theft or fraud instead of making off without payment
- Using Barton and Booth for dishonesty
- Using a heading for each offence
- Mentioning R v Allen
Show answer
Analysing theft or fraud instead of making off without payment. Choosing the correct offence is the first step.
- A scenario clearly involves a driver hitting a pedestrian; the only real dispute is whether the pedestrian's own carelessness reduces damages. You should
- write equally long sections on every element
- ignore the defence because it is partial
- deal briefly with duty and breach, and spend most time on contributory negligence
- discuss only the facts
Show answer
deal briefly with duty and breach, and spend most time on contributory negligence. Focus where the dispute is.
- What do the four letters of IRAC stand for?
Show answer
Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion.. A method for every element.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
- Crown Prosecution Service: Offences against the person, incorporating the Charging Standard
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.