All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
Discharge by frustration and the 1943 Act
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
A contract is frustrated when, after it is made, an event outside the parties' control makes performance impossible, illegal or radically different. Both parties are released for the future.
When frustration applies
- Destruction of the subject matter: *Taylor v Caldwell* (1863).
- Personal incapacity in a personal service contract: *Condor v Baron Knights* (1966).
- Supervening illegality: *Fibrosa v Fairbairn* (1943).
- Loss of the whole commercial purpose: *Krell v Henry* (1903); compare *Herne Bay Steam Boat v Hutton* (1903), where the whole purpose was not lost, so there was no frustration.
When it does not apply
- Performance just becomes more difficult or expensive: *Davis Contractors v Fareham UDC* (1956).
- Self-induced frustration: *Maritime National Fish v Ocean Trawlers* (1935).
- The event was foreseeable or is covered by a force majeure clause in the contract.
Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Act 1943
- s1(2): money paid before the frustrating event can be recovered, and money payable stops being payable. The court may let the payee keep or recover expenses, up to the sums paid or payable, if just.
- s1(3): a party who has received a valuable benefit before the event may have to pay a just sum for it.
Worked example
Problem: A band books a hall for a concert and pays a deposit of 10000 dollars. Before the date, the hall burns down without fault. The hall owner spent 2500 dollars preparing for the event. What happens to the deposit?
- Issue: is the contract frustrated?
- Rule: destruction of the subject matter frustrates a contract (Taylor v Caldwell).
- Apply: under s1(2) the deposit is recoverable, but the court may allow the owner to keep up to 2500 for expenses.
- Conclusion: the band likely recovers 7500 to 10000 dollars, at the court's discretion.
Answer: Frustrated; deposit recoverable, less up to 2500 for expenses.
Check yourself
- Krell v Henry is authority that a contract can be frustrated when
- the subject matter is destroyed by fire
- performance becomes more expensive
- one party changes its mind
- an outside event destroys its whole commercial purpose
Show answer
an outside event destroys its whole commercial purpose. Loss of the entire commercial purpose.
- Why is Herne Bay Steam Boat v Hutton contrasted with Krell v Henry?
- The boat sank, so there was frustration
- The whole purpose was not lost, so there was no frustration
- The hirer was at fault
- The contract was illegal
Show answer
The whole purpose was not lost, so there was no frustration. Frustration requires loss of the whole commercial purpose.
- A builder's costs rise sharply because of a shortage of workers. Applying Davis Contractors v Fareham, the contract is
- frustrated automatically
- void for mistake
- frustrated if the builder is losing money
- not frustrated, because it is only more expensive to perform
Show answer
not frustrated, because it is only more expensive to perform. Hardship or expense is not frustration.
- Maritime National Fish v Ocean Trawlers shows there is no frustration where
- the party relying on it caused the problem by its own choice
- the subject matter is destroyed
- performance becomes illegal
- a performer falls ill
Show answer
the party relying on it caused the problem by its own choice. Self-induced frustration does not count.
- A buyer paid a 10000 dollar deposit before a contract was frustrated. The court allows the seller to keep 2500 for expenses under s1(2) of the 1943 Act. How much does the buyer recover?
Show answer
7500 dollars. 10000 - 2500 = 7500.
- Define frustration of contract.
Show answer
An event after the contract is made, which is not the fault of either party, makes performance impossible, illegal or radically different, so the contract ends.. Three ingredients: later event, no fault, impossibility or radical change.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Frustrated contracts
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.