All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
Discharge by performance, agreement and breach
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
Discharge means the contract comes to an end and the parties are released from their obligations. The specification lists performance, agreement, breach and frustration (next lesson).
Performance
The general rule is complete and exact performance before payment is due (*Cutter v Powell*, 1795), which can cause injustice. Exceptions:
- Divisible contracts: payment for completed parts (*Ritchie v Atkinson*, 1808).
- Substantial performance: the contract price less the cost of putting defects right; compare *Hoenig v Isaacs* (1952) with *Bolton v Mahadeva* (1972).
- Acceptance of part performance, freely accepted (*Sumpter v Hedges*, 1898).
- Tender of performance refused by the other party (*Startup v Macdonald*, 1843).
- Prevention by the other party: payment for work done (*Planche v Colburn*, 1831).
Agreement
The parties can agree to end the contract. If both still have obligations, each gives up its rights (bilateral discharge, consideration on both sides). If one side has fully performed, release needs fresh consideration (accord and satisfaction) or a deed.
Breach
- Actual breach: failing to perform, or performing defectively, when performance is due.
- Anticipatory breach: one party says in advance it will not perform. The innocent party can sue at once or wait for the performance date.
- Breach of a condition, or a serious breach of an innominate term, lets the innocent party treat the contract as ended (repudiatory breach); any breach gives damages.
Worked example
Problem: Tomas agrees to build a garden wall for 3,000 dollars, payable on completion. He builds two-thirds, then abandons the job. The owner finishes it herself. Can Tomas claim anything?
- Issue: entire contract, partly performed.
- Rule: complete performance is required (Cutter v Powell); payment for part performance only if freely accepted (Sumpter v Hedges).
- Apply: the owner had no real choice but to finish a wall on her own land, so she did not freely accept part performance; this is not substantial performance either.
- Conclusion: Tomas probably recovers nothing.
Answer: Probably nothing: no substantial performance or free acceptance.
Check yourself
- Cutter v Powell is the leading case for which rule?
- Substantial performance earns the full price
- Complete performance is required before payment under an entire contract
- Frustration always allows recovery
- Part performance must always be paid for
Show answer
Complete performance is required before payment under an entire contract. The strict entire-obligations rule.
- A decorator finishes a flat with minor defects costing a small sum to fix. The likely outcome is
- nothing, because performance was not exact
- the full price with no deduction
- termination by the owner and no payment
- the contract price less the cost of the repairs
Show answer
the contract price less the cost of the repairs. Substantial performance, as in Hoenig v Isaacs.
- Under Sumpter v Hedges, payment for part performance is due when
- any work has been done
- the other party freely accepts the part performance
- the contract is divisible
- the other party prevents completion
Show answer
the other party freely accepts the part performance. Acceptance must be free; a landowner left with half-built work has no real choice.
- Two months before a concert, a band emails that it will not perform. This is
- not a breach until the concert date
- frustration
- anticipatory breach, so the organiser can sue immediately
- discharge by agreement
Show answer
anticipatory breach, so the organiser can sue immediately. Advance refusal to perform is anticipatory breach.
- Planche v Colburn shows that where the other party prevents completion, the party performing
- can recover payment for work done
- loses all rights
- must finish anyway
- can claim only nominal damages
Show answer
can recover payment for work done. Prevention is an exception to the entire-obligations rule.
- What is the doctrine of substantial performance?
Show answer
Where a party has performed almost everything, with only minor defects, they can claim the contract price minus the cost of putting the defects right.. Hoenig v Isaacs.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Discharge of a contract through performance
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.