All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.10)
Remedies for the individual: damages and injunctions
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.10)
Section 2.3.10 covers damages and injunctions for the individual: defamation, privacy, occupiers' liability and trespass. Pearson's planner asks you to explain how damages are calculated, how injunctions are granted, mitigation of loss, and the likely terms of an injunction.
Damages
- Compensatory damages restore the claimant, as far as money can, to the position before the wrong: lost earnings and costs (special damages) plus pain, suffering and loss of amenity (general damages).
- Mitigation: the claimant must take reasonable steps to limit the loss; loss that could reasonably have been avoided is not recoverable.
- Contributory negligence reduces damages in occupiers' liability claims.
- Nominal damages mark the infringement of a right where there is no real loss, as in trespass, which is actionable without damage.
- In trespass, damages may be a reasonable licence fee or mesne profits for the use of the land; in defamation, damages compensate for harm to reputation; in human rights cases damages are awarded only if needed for just satisfaction (s8 HRA).
Injunctions
Equitable and discretionary: granted where damages would not be an adequate remedy.
- Prohibitory: stops conduct, such as further publication of a defamatory statement or a continuing trespass.
- Mandatory: orders a positive act, such as removing an encroaching sign.
- Interim: before trial, to hold the position; before restraining publication, s12 HRA requires the applicant to show it is likely to succeed at trial and the court to give weight to freedom of expression.
- Drafting the terms: say who is restrained, what exactly they must or must not do, where, and for how long, for example: 'The defendant must not enter the claimant's land at 4 River Lane, or permit others to do so, until further order.'
- Statutory remedies add to these: s12 (summary of judgment) and s13 (removal) of the Defamation Act 2013.
Worked example
Problem: Ines trips on a loose paving slab in the forecourt of Kemal's shop and cannot work for 15 days, losing 120 dollars a day. She refused, without good reason, a free taxi her employer offered, which would have let her return to work 5 days earlier. Calculate her loss of earnings award, applying mitigation.
- Total lost earnings claimed: 15 x 120 = 1800 dollars.
- Mitigation: she unreasonably refused help that would have shortened her absence by 5 days.
- Recoverable: 10 x 120 = 1200 dollars.
- General damages for pain and suffering are added separately; any contributory negligence would then reduce the whole award.
Answer: 1200 dollars for lost earnings.
Check yourself
- Using the Ines example: 15 days lost at 120 dollars a day, but 5 days could reasonably have been avoided. How much is recoverable?
Show answer
1200 dollars. (15 - 5) x 120 = 1200.
- Which remedy would order a neighbour to take down a sign overhanging the claimant's land?
- A mandatory injunction
- A prohibitory injunction
- Nominal damages
- A declaration of incompatibility
Show answer
A mandatory injunction. A mandatory injunction orders a positive act.
- Why might a court award nominal damages for trespass to land?
- Because the claimant was at fault
- Because the trespasser was a child
- Because trespass is actionable without proof of damage
- Because injunctions are never available for trespass
Show answer
Because trespass is actionable without proof of damage. To mark the infringement of a right.
- Before granting an interim injunction to stop a newspaper publishing, s12 HRA requires the court to
- ban publication automatically if privacy is claimed
- be satisfied the applicant is likely to establish at trial that publication should not be allowed
- consult the European Court of Human Rights
- award damages first
Show answer
be satisfied the applicant is likely to establish at trial that publication should not be allowed. s12(3) and particular regard to freedom of expression.
- Which is the best-drafted term for an injunction against a trespasser?
- The defendant must behave better
- The defendant should think about the claimant's feelings
- The defendant must pay whatever the claimant asks
- The defendant must not enter the claimant's land at 4 River Lane, or allow others to do so, until further order
Show answer
The defendant must not enter the claimant's land at 4 River Lane, or allow others to do so, until further order. Clear on who, what, where and how long.
- When will a court grant an injunction rather than leave the claimant to damages?
Show answer
When damages would not be an adequate remedy, for example where a trespass or publication is continuing, and it is fair to grant this discretionary remedy.. Equitable discretion.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Defamation Act 2013
- legislation.gov.uk: Human Rights Act 1998
- Digestible Notes: Trespass to land cases
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.