All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.6)
Making off without payment: s3 Theft Act 1978
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.6)
Section 3 Theft Act 1978: a person who, knowing that payment on the spot for goods supplied or services done is required or expected from him, dishonestly makes off without having paid as required or expected, and with intent to avoid payment, commits an offence. No deception is needed.
Actus reus
- Makes off: departs or leaves the place where payment is due (*R v Brooks and Brooks*, 1983). If caught before leaving, the charge is attempt (*R v McDavitt*, 1981).
- Goods supplied or services done, but not where the supply is unlawful or payment is not legally enforceable (s3(3)).
- Payment on the spot required or expected: 'on the spot' is not a fixed place; what matters is that liability to pay has arisen (*R v Aziz*, 1993). If payment has not yet become due, the offence is not committed (*Troughton v MPC*, 1987).
- Without paying as required: if the supplier agrees to defer payment, no payment is required on the spot (*R v Vincent*, 2001).
Mens rea
- Knowledge that payment on the spot is required or expected.
- Dishonesty: Ivey, as applied in Barton and Booth (the June 2025 examiner report credited Barton and Booth).
- Intention to avoid payment permanently: *R v Allen* (1985, House of Lords). Intending to pay later is not enough for the offence.
Worked example
Problem: Callum eats a three-course meal at a restaurant and slips out of a side door while the waiter fetches the bill, intending never to pay. He then takes a taxi home and runs off at the end of the journey without paying. Is he guilty under s3?
- Restaurant: goods supplied and services done; payment was due on the spot at the end of the meal; he left the premises (makes off); he knew payment was expected, acted dishonestly by ordinary decent standards (Barton and Booth) and intended never to pay (Allen).
- Taxi: a service done; payment is expected on the spot at the end of the journey; he ran off without paying, intending never to pay.
- If the restaurant had agreed that he could pay next week, Vincent would mean no payment was required on the spot.
- Conclusion: liable for two offences of making off without payment. The June 2025 report stressed choosing making off, not theft, fraud or obtaining services dishonestly, where someone leaves without paying.
Answer: Two offences under s3.
Check yourself
- What did R v Allen (1985) decide about the mens rea of making off without payment?
- An intention to delay payment is enough
- No intention is needed
- The defendant must have deceived the victim
- The defendant must intend to avoid payment permanently
Show answer
The defendant must intend to avoid payment permanently. An intention to avoid payment permanently is required.
- A guest agrees with the hotel owner to pay next week, then never pays. Following R v Vincent
- he is guilty of making off
- payment was not required on the spot, so there is no s3 offence
- he is guilty of robbery
- the agreement is irrelevant
Show answer
payment was not required on the spot, so there is no s3 offence. Agreed deferral means no payment is due on the spot.
- A diner is stopped at the restaurant door before leaving without paying. Following R v McDavitt, the right charge is
- making off without payment
- fraud by false representation
- no offence
- attempted making off without payment
Show answer
attempted making off without payment. He had not yet made off.
- Following Troughton v MPC, there is no s3 offence where
- liability to pay has not yet arisen, so payment is not yet required on the spot
- the service was a taxi ride
- the defendant paid by card
- the defendant left on foot
Show answer
liability to pay has not yet arisen, so payment is not yet required on the spot. Payment must be due on the spot.
- Which statement about making off without payment is correct?
- The defendant must make a false representation
- It applies only to restaurants
- No deception is needed
- It requires force
Show answer
No deception is needed. It was created to fill gaps in the deception offences.
- State the elements of making off without payment under s3 Theft Act 1978.
Show answer
Knowing payment on the spot is required or expected, the defendant dishonestly makes off without having paid, intending to avoid payment.. Knowledge, dishonesty, making off, intent to avoid payment.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Making off without payment
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.