All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.7)
Criminal Damage Act 1971: s1 and lawful excuse under s5
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.7)
Criminal damage protects property. The specification covers basic criminal damage (s1(1)) and the defence of lawful excuse (s5), and Pearson's course planner also mentions the aggravated and arson forms.
Basic criminal damage, s1(1)
A person who without lawful excuse destroys or damages any property belonging to another, intending to destroy or damage it or being reckless as to whether it would be destroyed or damaged.
- Damage includes temporary impairment of value or usefulness (*Morphitis v Salmon*, 1990; *R v Fiak*, 2005) and anything that costs money to put right, even if the cleaning was not strictly necessary (*Roe v Kingerlee*, 1986; *Hardman v Chief Constable of Avon*, 1986).
- Recklessness is subjective: aware of a risk and unreasonable to take it (*R v G and R*, 2003, overruling *MPC v Caldwell*).
- A genuine belief that the property is your own means no mens rea, even if the mistake is one of law (*R v Smith*, 1974).
Aggravated damage and arson
- s1(2): destroying or damaging any property, including your own, intending or being reckless as to endangering life by the damage. The danger must come from the damage itself (*R v Steer*, 1987), but life need not actually be endangered (*R v Sangha*, 1988).
- s1(3): damage by fire is charged as arson.
Lawful excuse, s5
Applies to s1(1) (not s1(2)). The defendant has a lawful excuse if he believed:
- s5(2)(a): that the person entitled to consent had consented, or would have consented if they had known the circumstances; or
- s5(2)(b): that the property was in immediate need of protection and the means used were reasonable.
- s5(3): the belief need only be honestly held, not reasonable. It can even be a drunken belief (*Jaggard v Dickinson*, 1981).
Worked example
Problem: After a party, Mia, very drunk, smashes a window to get into a house she believes is her friend Jo's, who has said she can stay any time. It is actually a neighbour's house. Is Mia guilty of criminal damage?
- Actus reus: she damaged property belonging to another (the window).
- Mens rea: she intended the damage.
- Lawful excuse: under s5(2)(a) she believed the owner (as she thought, Jo) would consent; under s5(3) the belief need only be honest.
- Conclusion: following Jaggard v Dickinson, her drunken but honest belief gives her a lawful excuse, so she is not guilty of s1(1).
Answer: Not guilty: s5(2)(a) and Jaggard v Dickinson.
Check yourself
- In Jaggard v Dickinson the defendant had a lawful excuse because
- the owner did consent
- she honestly believed the owner would have consented, even though she was drunk
- her belief was reasonable
- the property was hers
Show answer
she honestly believed the owner would have consented, even though she was drunk. s5(3) makes an honest belief enough.
- Protesters paint water-soluble pictures on a pavement that would wash away in rain, but the council pays to clean them. Following Hardman
- it is not damage, because it was temporary
- it is not damage, because rain would remove it
- only permanent damage counts
- this is damage, because cleaning costs were incurred
Show answer
this is damage, because cleaning costs were incurred. Expense of restoration counts as damage, even if unnecessary.
- Under s5(2)(b), a defendant has a lawful excuse if he believed
- the property was worthless
- property was in immediate need of protection and the means used were reasonable
- the owner deserved the damage
- the police would approve
Show answer
property was in immediate need of protection and the means used were reasonable. Protection of property.
- For aggravated criminal damage under s1(2), R v Steer requires that
- someone is actually killed
- the property belongs to another
- the danger to life comes from the damage to property itself
- the defendant intended to kill
Show answer
the danger to life comes from the damage to property itself. Danger must arise from the damage, not just from the act.
- A tenant removes wall panels he installed, believing wrongly that they are his. Under R v Smith (1974) he
- lacks mens rea, because he believed the property was his
- is guilty because the mistake was about the law
- is guilty of aggravated damage
- has a s5(2)(b) defence
Show answer
lacks mens rea, because he believed the property was his. Even a mistake of law can negate mens rea here.
- Explain the lawful excuse defence in s5 Criminal Damage Act 1971.
Show answer
The defendant is not guilty if he honestly believed the owner had consented or would consent, or that the property needed immediate protection and his actions were reasonable; the belief need only be honest, not reasonable.. s5(2)(a), (b) and (3).
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Criminal damage
- e-lawresources: Intoxication and criminal liability
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.