All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.8)
Remedies for the market: damages and injunctions
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.8)
The specification says remedies apply to the whole of section 2.1, not just one topic. Know how damages are calculated and limited, and when an injunction will be granted.
Damages for breach of contract
Aim: to put the claimant in the position they would have been in if the contract had been performed (expectation loss).
- Remoteness: recoverable losses are those arising naturally from the breach, or which both parties reasonably contemplated as likely when contracting (*Hadley v Baxendale*, 1854). In *Victoria Laundry v Newman Industries* (1949) normal lost profits from a late boiler were recovered, but exceptionally lucrative dyeing contracts the supplier did not know about were not.
- Measure: if the cost of cure is out of all proportion to the benefit, the court awards the difference in value instead. In *Ruxley Electronics v Forsyth* (1995) a pool built 6 ft deep instead of 7.5 ft cost about 21,000 to rebuild but had not lost value; the owner got 2,500 for loss of amenity.
- Mitigation: the claimant must take reasonable steps to reduce the loss and cannot recover loss that reasonable steps would have avoided.
Damages in tort
Aim: to put the claimant in the position they would have been in if the tort had not happened. Remoteness uses the Wagon Mound reasonable foreseeability test. Damages may be reduced for contributory negligence, and the claimant must mitigate.
Injunctions
An injunction is an equitable remedy, granted at the court's discretion where damages would be inadequate.
- A prohibitory injunction orders a party not to do something; a mandatory injunction orders them to do something.
- A court will not order someone to perform personal services, but it may enforce a negative promise. In *Warner Brothers v Nelson* (1936) an actress was restrained, for up to three years, from acting for a rival studio.
- It will refuse if the injunction would in effect force performance or is unfair: in *Page One Records v Britton* (1967) a manager could not stop a band using another manager, because that would force them to keep a manager they no longer trusted.
Worked example
Problem: A courier fails to deliver a part for a factory machine on time. The factory loses its normal profits for a week and also a one-off government contract the courier knew nothing about. What damages can the factory recover?
- Rule: losses arising naturally, or within both parties' contemplation, are recoverable (Hadley v Baxendale).
- Apply: normal lost profits from a stopped machine arise naturally from late delivery of a part.
- The special government contract was unknown to the courier, so like the dyeing contracts in Victoria Laundry it is too remote.
- Conclusion: normal profits only, provided the factory took reasonable steps to mitigate, for example by sourcing the part elsewhere.
Answer: Normal lost profits only.
Check yourself
- Under Hadley v Baxendale, which losses are recoverable for breach of contract?
- Any loss caused by the breach, however unusual
- Only losses the claimant has insured
- Losses arising naturally, or which the parties reasonably contemplated when contracting
- Only losses agreed in writing
Show answer
Losses arising naturally, or which the parties reasonably contemplated when contracting. The two limbs of the remoteness test.
- In Victoria Laundry, why were the profits from special dyeing contracts not recovered?
- The supplier did not know about those contracts
- The laundry failed to mitigate
- The boiler arrived on time
- Profits can never be recovered
Show answer
The supplier did not know about those contracts. Unknown special circumstances are too remote.
- In Ruxley v Forsyth the cost of rebuilding the pool was about 21000 and the award for loss of amenity was 2500. How much less than the cost of cure was awarded?
Show answer
18500 pounds. 21000 - 2500 = 18500.
- The principle from Ruxley Electronics v Forsyth is that
- cost of cure is always awarded
- cost of cure is not awarded where it is out of all proportion to the benefit
- damages for loss of amenity are never available
- builders can never be sued
Show answer
cost of cure is not awarded where it is out of all proportion to the benefit. Diminution in value, or a loss of amenity award, instead.
- What did the court do in Warner Brothers v Nelson?
- Ordered her to act for Warner Brothers
- Refused any remedy
- Awarded only nominal damages
- Granted an injunction stopping the actress working for a rival, limited to three years
Show answer
Granted an injunction stopping the actress working for a rival, limited to three years. A negative injunction, not specific performance.
- A wedding venue cancels in breach of contract. The couple could easily book an equally good venue for the same price but instead book one costing twice as much. The extra cost is probably
- recoverable in full
- not recoverable, because they failed to mitigate
- recoverable as punitive damages
- recoverable only by injunction
Show answer
not recoverable, because they failed to mitigate. Loss that reasonable steps would have avoided is not recoverable.
- Why might a court refuse an injunction even where a contract has been broken?
Show answer
Because an injunction is an equitable, discretionary remedy: it will be refused if damages are adequate or if it would in effect force someone to perform personal services.. Equitable remedies are not available as of right.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- Hall Ellis Solicitors: Remoteness and reasonably foreseeable damages
- isurv: Ruxley Electronics v Forsyth (case record)
- swarb: Warner Brothers Pictures v Nelson (1936)
- swarb: Page One Records Ltd v Britton (1967)
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.