All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.1)
Actus reus: voluntary acts and omissions
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.1)
Most crimes need an actus reus (the guilty act) and a mens rea (the guilty mind). Breaking a statutory definition into these two parts is the first skill in criminal law.
What actus reus covers
The actus reus is every part of the offence except the mental element: the conduct (an act or omission), any circumstances and any consequence. The conduct must be voluntary.
Example: theft (s1(1) Theft Act 1968). Actus reus: appropriation of property belonging to another. Mens rea: dishonestly, with intention to permanently deprive.
Omissions: the general rule and the duties
English law imposes no general duty to act: you need not rescue a drowning stranger. An omission is criminal only where the defendant is under a duty to act:
| Duty | Case | Facts in brief |
|---|---|---|
| Contract | R v Pittwood (1902) | Level-crossing keeper left the gate open; manslaughter |
| Special relationship | R v Gibbins and Proctor (1918) | Father and partner starved his child; murder |
| Voluntary assumption of care | R v Stone and Dobinson (1977) | Took in a frail relative and failed to care for her; manslaughter |
| Creating a dangerous situation | R v Miller (1983) | Squatter started a fire by accident and failed to deal with it; criminal damage |
| Statute | For example, failing to provide a breath specimen | The statute itself makes the failure an offence |
Sources: The Student Lawyer, Liability for omissions; Pearson June 2025 examiner report (Pittwood, Stone and Dobinson)
Offences against the person as examples
The specification uses the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 to illustrate liability (a separate lesson covers ss47, 20 and 18). For each offence you should be able to say which words are actus reus and which are mens rea.
Worked example
Problem: Zara, a lifeguard paid by a hotel, chats on her phone while a guest drowns in the pool. A guest sunbathing nearby also does nothing. Who has an actus reus?
- Issue: liability for omissions.
- Rule: no general duty to act, but a contractual duty creates one (R v Pittwood).
- Apply: Zara's contract of employment requires her to watch the pool, so her failure is an actus reus. The sunbather has no duty.
- Conclusion: Zara may be liable for manslaughter (subject to causation and fault); the sunbather is not liable however morally wrong his inaction.
Answer: Zara only: contractual duty.
Check yourself
- R v Pittwood is authority for a duty to act arising from
- a family relationship
- creating a dangerous situation
- a statute
- a contract
Show answer
a contract. He was employed to shut the gate.
- In R v Miller a squatter accidentally set fire to a mattress, moved to another room and did nothing. His liability arose from
- a contractual duty
- creating a dangerous situation and failing to act
- a special relationship with the owner
- a voluntary assumption of care
Show answer
creating a dangerous situation and failing to act. Creating a danger imposes a duty to take reasonable steps.
- Stone and Dobinson were liable for manslaughter because they
- were paid carers
- set fire to her room
- were her parents
- voluntarily took on the care of a frail relative and then neglected her
Show answer
voluntarily took on the care of a frail relative and then neglected her. Voluntary assumption of care.
- A passer-by watches a stranger drown in a shallow pond and does nothing. Under English law he is
- not criminally liable, because there is no general duty to act
- guilty of murder
- guilty of manslaughter by omission
- liable because of a moral duty
Show answer
not criminally liable, because there is no general duty to act. No general duty to rescue strangers.
- In theft, which of these is part of the actus reus?
- Dishonesty
- Intention to permanently deprive
- Appropriation of property belonging to another
- Belief in a legal right
Show answer
Appropriation of property belonging to another. The other options are mental elements.
- What is meant by an omission in criminal law?
Show answer
A failure to act, which is only criminal where the defendant was under a legal duty to act, for example under a contract.. The 4-mark answer: definition plus duty plus case.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- The Student Lawyer: Liability for omissions
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.