All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.2)
Mens rea: intention, recklessness and transferred malice
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.2)
Mens rea is the mental element. The specification focuses on intention (direct and oblique), subjective recklessness and transferred malice.
Intention
- Direct intention: the consequence is the defendant's aim or purpose.
- Oblique (indirect) intention: the defendant does not aim at the result but it is a side effect. The jury may find intention only if the result was a virtual certainty (barring some unforeseen intervention) as a result of the defendant's actions and the defendant appreciated that this was the case (*R v Nedrick*, 1986, approved with changes in *R v Woollin*, 1999).
- Motive is different from intention: a good motive does not remove intention (*R v Inglis*, 2010; *R v Moloney*, 1985).
- Section 8 Criminal Justice Act 1967: foresight is judged on all the evidence, not by an objective natural-and-probable-consequence test.
Subjective recklessness
The defendant is aware of a risk and goes on to take it when it is unreasonable to do so. Pearson's course planner points to *R v Cunningham* (1957). For criminal damage, *R v G and R* (2003) overruled the objective *Caldwell* test and restored a subjective test based on awareness of the risk. Recklessness is the minimum mens rea for assault, battery, s47 and s20.
Transferred malice and coincidence
Transferred malice: if D intends to harm X but harms Y instead, the mens rea transfers to the offence against Y, provided it is the same type of offence (aiming a punch at one person and hitting another).
The actus reus and mens rea must coincide in time, though a continuing act can bring them together.
Worked example
Problem: To claim insurance, Omar sets fire to his own shop at night, knowing his tenant sleeps upstairs. He hopes she escapes, but she dies. Did Omar intend to kill?
- Issue: no direct intention (his aim was money), so consider oblique intention.
- Rule: Woollin: death or serious harm must be a virtual certainty and Omar must appreciate that.
- Apply: setting fire to a building with a sleeping occupant may make serious harm virtually certain, and he knew she was there.
- Conclusion: the jury may find intention, but it is for them; if not, he is likely guilty of manslaughter. Evaluation: the word 'may' gives the jury flexibility but less certainty.
Answer: Possibly: a jury question under Woollin.
Check yourself
- Under Woollin, the jury may find oblique intention if
- death was a probable consequence
- a reasonable person would have foreseen death
- death or serious injury was a virtual certainty and the defendant appreciated this
- the defendant had a bad motive
Show answer
death or serious injury was a virtual certainty and the defendant appreciated this. Virtual certainty plus appreciation.
- Direct intention means
- the consequence was the defendant's aim or purpose
- the defendant foresaw the consequence as possible
- a reasonable person would foresee the consequence
- the defendant acted carelessly
Show answer
the consequence was the defendant's aim or purpose. Aim or purpose.
- Subjective recklessness requires that the defendant
- should have been aware of a risk
- wanted the harm to happen
- was aware of a risk and unreasonably took it
- was negligent
Show answer
was aware of a risk and unreasonably took it. Awareness is the key (Cunningham; G and R).
- R v G and R (2003) is important because it
- created the virtual certainty test
- overruled Caldwell and restored a subjective test of recklessness
- abolished transferred malice
- defined dishonesty
Show answer
overruled Caldwell and restored a subjective test of recklessness. Two boys set fire to newspapers; the objective test was unjust.
- Ada throws a stone at Ben intending to injure him; it misses and injures Cal. Ada's mens rea
- does not exist, because she did not aim at Cal
- transfers only if Cal is a relative
- becomes negligence
- transfers to the offence against Cal
Show answer
transfers to the offence against Cal. Transferred malice: same type of offence.
- Explain oblique intention.
Show answer
Where the result is not the defendant's aim, but it is a virtually certain consequence of their actions and the defendant appreciated this, the jury may find intention (Woollin).. Nedrick and Woollin.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Mens rea, intention
- e-lawresources: Criminal damage
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.