All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.1)
Actus reus: causation
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.1)
For result crimes (such as murder or s47 ABH) the prosecution must prove the defendant's conduct caused the consequence, in fact and in law.
Factual causation
The but for test: but for the defendant's conduct, would the result have happened when it did? *R v White* (1910) is the standard authority for the but for test: if the result would have happened anyway, at that time, the defendant did not cause it in fact.
Legal causation
- The conduct must be more than a minimal cause; it need not be the only cause (*R v Benge*, 1865).
- Thin skull rule: take your victim as you find them, including their beliefs. In *R v Blaue* (1975), following *R v Holland* (1841), the rule applied where the victim refused medical treatment that would have saved her; the defendant's act remained the cause.
- The chain can be broken by a novus actus interveniens (new intervening act).
Intervening acts
| Intervening act | Rule | Case |
|---|---|---|
| Third party | A third party's act breaks the chain unless it was foreseeable | R v Pagett (1983) |
| Victim's own act | No break unless the victim's reaction was disproportionate or unreasonable | R v Roberts (1971); R v Williams and Davis (1992) |
| Victim's free choice | A free, deliberate and informed act by an adult of sound mind breaks the chain | R v Kennedy (2007); but see R v Wallace (2018) |
| Medical treatment | Courts rarely find a break; the treatment must be extraordinary | R v Jordan (1956); R v Smith (1959); R v Cheshire (1991) |
Source: e-lawresources, Causation in criminal liability
Worked example
Problem: Dan threatens Ella with a knife in his car. She jumps out at 20 mph and breaks her leg. Did Dan cause her injury?
- Factual causation: but for Dan's threats, she would not have jumped.
- Legal causation: is her jump a novus actus? Under R v Roberts the victim's own act breaks the chain only if it was disproportionate or unreasonable.
- Apply: jumping from a slow car to escape a knife is a foreseeable reaction.
- Conclusion: Dan caused the injury and may be liable for s47 ABH (or s20 if the harm is serious).
Answer: Yes: the escape was foreseeable (R v Roberts).
Check yourself
- D poisons V intending to kill, but V dies of an unrelated heart attack before the poison has any effect. Applying R v White, D
- caused the death, because he intended it
- did not cause the death, so at most attempted murder
- caused the death under the thin skull rule
- is liable because the poison was a substantial cause
Show answer
did not cause the death, so at most attempted murder. The death would have happened anyway: the but for test fails.
- A stabbing victim refuses medical treatment that would have saved her and dies. Under R v Blaue
- her refusal broke the chain
- the doctors caused the death
- the defendant is liable only for the wound
- the defendant still caused the death: he takes the victim as he finds her
Show answer
the defendant still caused the death: he takes the victim as he finds her. The thin skull rule applies to a refusal of treatment.
- According to R v Pagett, when does a third party's act NOT break the chain of causation?
- When the third party acted deliberately
- When the third party's act was foreseeable
- Never: third-party acts always break the chain
- Only when the third party is a doctor
Show answer
When the third party's act was foreseeable. A foreseeable third-party act does not break the chain.
- Which intervening act is most likely to break the chain of causation?
- A victim running from an attacker into a road
- Ordinary negligent medical treatment
- A free, deliberate and informed decision by an adult to inject a drug himself
- A victim refusing a blood transfusion
Show answer
A free, deliberate and informed decision by an adult to inject a drug himself. R v Kennedy (2007).
- R v Benge shows the defendant's conduct
- need not be the only cause but must be more than minimal
- must be the sole cause
- must be the last act before the result
- is irrelevant if others were also careless
Show answer
need not be the only cause but must be more than minimal. Other causes can contribute.
- What is a novus actus interveniens?
Show answer
A new, independent intervening act by a third party, the victim or nature, which is unforeseeable and breaks the chain of causation between the defendant's act and the result.. Latin for a new intervening act.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Causation in criminal liability
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.