All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
Vitiating factors: misrepresentation
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
A misrepresentation is a false statement of fact or law, made by one party to the other, which induces the contract. It makes the contract voidable.
Is it actionable?
- False statement of fact or law. Opinion is not usually enough (*Bisset v Wilkinson*, 1927; *Esso v Mardon*, 1976, is cited in contrast) unless the speaker was in a position to know the facts (*Smith v Land and House Property*, 1884). A statement of intention the speaker never had is a statement of fact (*Edgington v Fitzmaurice*, 1885).
- Silence is not usually a misrepresentation (*Smith v Hughes*, 1871), but a statement that becomes false before the contract must be corrected (*With v O'Flanagan*, 1936).
- Inducement: the claimant must have relied on it. No reliance if they checked for themselves (*Attwood v Small*, 1838) or never knew of it (*Horsfall v Thomas*, 1862), but failing to check when given the chance does not prevent reliance (*Redgrave v Hurd*, 1881).
Types and remedies
| Type | Test | Remedies |
|---|---|---|
| Fraudulent | Made knowingly, without belief in its truth, or recklessly (Derry v Peek, 1889) | Rescission and damages in the tort of deceit for all direct loss (Doyle v Olby, 1969) |
| Negligent (s2(1) Misrepresentation Act 1967) | Liable unless the maker proves reasonable grounds to believe, and did believe, the statement true (Howard Marine v Ogden, 1978) | Rescission and damages as if fraudulent (Royscott Trust v Rogerson, 1991) |
| Wholly innocent | Maker had reasonable grounds | Rescission, or damages in lieu at the court's discretion (s2(2)) |
Sources: e-lawresources, Misrepresentation; Misrepresentation Act 1967
Bars to rescission and contributory negligence
Rescission is lost by affirmation (*Long v Lloyd*, 1958), lapse of time (*Leaf v International Galleries*, 1950), third-party rights (*Car and Universal Finance v Caldwell*, 1964), or if the parties cannot be restored to their original positions. Section 3 of the 1967 Act makes a clause excluding liability for misrepresentation subject to the UCTA reasonableness test. Damages for negligent misrepresentation can be reduced for the claimant's own fault under the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945, as the specification notes.
Worked example
Problem: Tomasz buys a used delivery van from a dealer, who tells him it has 'never been used for towing'. The dealer's own service records, which he had read, show years of heavy towing. Tomasz did not ask to see the records. Soon the gearbox fails. What are his rights?
- Issue: actionable misrepresentation?
- Rule: a false statement of fact (the van's past use) which induced the contract; failing to check when given the chance does not stop reliance (Redgrave v Hurd).
- Apply: the dealer had read the records, so the statement is likely fraudulent (Derry v Peek) or at least negligent, as he cannot show reasonable grounds for believing it under s2(1).
- Conclusion: Tomasz can rescind if no bar applies (he must act promptly and not affirm) and claim damages; the s2(1) route is easier to prove than fraud.
Answer: Rescission plus damages, most easily under s2(1).
Check yourself
- A seller of a house says, 'I think the garden gets plenty of sun', having no special knowledge. Following Bisset v Wilkinson, this is
- an opinion, so not usually a misrepresentation
- a statement of fact
- a term of the contract
- a fraudulent statement
Show answer
an opinion, so not usually a misrepresentation. Honest opinion is not a statement of fact, unless the speaker was in a position to know the facts.
- A seller truthfully states his business income, but before the contract is signed the income falls sharply. Under With v O'Flanagan he must
- say nothing, because silence is never misrepresentation
- lower the price automatically
- disclose the change
- repeat the statement in writing
Show answer
disclose the change. A statement that becomes false must be corrected.
- Buyers employ their own surveyors to check the seller's claims. Under Attwood v Small they
- did not rely on the seller's statement
- relied on it because the seller made it first
- can always rescind
- are bound by any exclusion clause
Show answer
did not rely on the seller's statement. Checking for yourself shows you relied on your own checks.
- Under s2(1) Misrepresentation Act 1967, who has to prove what?
- The claimant must prove fraud
- The claimant must prove the maker was careless
- Nobody has to prove anything
- The maker must prove reasonable grounds for believing the statement true
Show answer
The maker must prove reasonable grounds for believing the statement true. The burden shifts to the maker, which makes s2(1) attractive to claimants.
- Which of these bars rescission?
- Discovering the truth within a week
- Affirming the contract after discovering the truth
- The misrepresentation being negligent
- The claimant being a consumer
Show answer
Affirming the contract after discovering the truth. Long v Lloyd: affirmation bars rescission.
- State the test for fraudulent misrepresentation from Derry v Peek.
Show answer
A false statement made knowingly, or without belief in its truth, or recklessly, careless whether it is true or false.. Lord Herschell's three-part test.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Misrepresentation
- legislation.gov.uk: Misrepresentation Act 1967
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.