All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
Vitiating factors: mistake
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.4)
Mistake makes a contract void only in narrow cases. A void contract never existed, so even innocent third parties get no rights.
Common mistake (both parties share the same mistake)
- Subject matter does not exist (res extincta): contract void (*Couturier v Hastie*, 1856; *Scott v Coulson*, 1903).
- Buyer already owns the property (res sua): *Cooper v Phibbs* (1867).
- Quality: void only if the subject matter is essentially and radically different from what was believed (*Bell v Lever Bros*, 1932; *Great Peace Shipping v Tsavliris*, 2002). *Leaf v International Galleries* (1950) is also cited here.
Mutual and unilateral mistake
- Mutual mistake (cross-purposes): if a reasonable person cannot find one meaning, the contract is void (*Raffles v Wichelhaus*, 1864).
- Unilateral mistake as to terms, known to the other party: *Hartog v Colin and Shields* (1939).
- Mistaken identity: at a distance the contract may be void if the claimant meant to deal only with an identifiable person (*Cundy v Lindsay*, 1878; *Shogun Finance v Hudson*, 2003). Face to face, the law presumes you intended to deal with the person in front of you, so the contract is voidable for fraud, not void (*Phillips v Brooks*, 1919; *Lewis v Avery*, 1971).
- Non est factum: signing a document fundamentally different from what you thought, without carelessness (*Saunders v Anglia Building Society*, 1970).
Worked example
Problem: A rogue visits Dev's house, pretends to be a famous actor and buys Dev's car with a cheque that bounces. The rogue sells the car to Ella, who buys in good faith. Can Dev recover the car?
- Issue: is the Dev and rogue contract void for mistaken identity, or voidable for fraud?
- Rule: face to face, the law presumes Dev intended to deal with the person present (Lewis v Avery; Phillips v Brooks).
- Apply: the contract is voidable, not void; Dev did not rescind before the sale to Ella.
- Conclusion: Ella gets good title. Dev's claim is against the rogue.
Answer: No: face-to-face dealing makes the contract voidable, and Ella took good title first.
Check yourself
- Two parties contract for the sale of a particular painting which, unknown to both, had been destroyed the day before. Following Couturier v Hastie the contract is
- voidable for misrepresentation
- void for common mistake
- valid, so the buyer must pay
- frustrated
Show answer
void for common mistake. The subject matter did not exist when the contract was made.
- Raffles v Wichelhaus is the standard example of
- common mistake as to quality
- unilateral mistake as to identity
- non est factum
- mutual mistake
Show answer
mutual mistake. The parties were at cross-purposes and no single meaning could be found.
- A rogue buys goods face to face by claiming to be someone else. The contract is normally
- void for mistake
- voidable for fraud
- valid and unchallengeable
- illegal
Show answer
voidable for fraud. Phillips v Brooks and Lewis v Avery: face-to-face presumption.
- Bell v Lever Bros shows that a common mistake as to quality
- always voids the contract
- never matters
- voids the contract only if it makes the thing essentially different
- is the same as misrepresentation
Show answer
voids the contract only if it makes the thing essentially different. The test is strict.
- A rogue orders goods by letter, signing with a name very like a real, respectable firm the seller knows. Following Cundy v Lindsay, the contract is
- void, because the seller intended to deal only with that firm
- voidable only
- valid
- frustrated
Show answer
void, because the seller intended to deal only with that firm. Dealing at a distance with an identifiable person.
- Why does it matter to an innocent third-party buyer whether a contract is void or voidable?
Show answer
If the first contract is void the rogue never had title, so the third party gets nothing; if it is voidable and not yet rescinded, the third party can get good title.. Void contracts pass no title.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Mistake in contract law
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.