All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2 note: nature of criminal liability)
Illustrating liability: ss47, 20 and 18 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2 note: nature of criminal liability)
The specification says ss18, 20 and 47 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 may be used to illustrate actus reus and mens rea. They also appear in intoxication problems.
Assault and battery first
Both are common law offences charged under s39 Criminal Justice Act 1988.
- Assault: intentionally or recklessly causing another to apprehend immediate unlawful force.
- Battery: intentionally or recklessly applying unlawful force to another.
Maximum: six months' imprisonment.
The three statutory offences
| Offence | Actus reus | Mens rea | Maximum |
|---|---|---|---|
| s47 assault occasioning actual bodily harm | An assault or battery causing harm that is more than transient and trifling (R v Donovan, 1934); psychiatric illness can count but not mere emotions (R v Chan-Fook, 1993) | Intention or recklessness as to the assault or battery only | 5 years |
| s20 unlawful wounding or inflicting GBH | A wound (break in the continuity of the skin) or grievous (really serious) harm | Intention or foresight that some harm might result (R v Savage; DPP v Parmenter, 1992) | 5 years |
| s18 wounding or causing GBH with intent | A wound or GBH | Specific intention to cause GBH (or to resist arrest) | Life |
Source: Crown Prosecution Service charging standard
Why the distinction matters
Section 47 has a 'constructive' mens rea: no foresight of harm is needed. Section 20 needs foresight of some harm, not serious harm. Section 18 needs intention, so it is a specific intent crime, while s47 and s20 are basic intent crimes, which matters for intoxication (see the intoxication lesson). The seriousness of injuries is judged in context, including the victim's age and health (*Bollom*, 2003).
Worked example
Problem: In a bar, Kai pushes Leo, meaning only to annoy him. Leo falls and breaks his arm. Which offence?
- Actus reus: a battery (the push) causing a broken arm, which is at least ABH and probably GBH (really serious harm).
- Mens rea for s18: no intention to cause GBH.
- Mens rea for s20: did Kai foresee that some harm might result? Pushing someone in a crowded bar makes it likely he did.
- Conclusion: s20 if foresight of some harm is proved; otherwise s47, which needs only intention or recklessness as to the battery.
Answer: s20 if Kai foresaw some harm; otherwise s47.
Check yourself
- What mens rea must be proved for s47 ABH?
- Intention to cause ABH
- Intention or recklessness as to the assault or battery only
- Foresight of serious harm
- Intention to kill
Show answer
Intention or recklessness as to the assault or battery only. No foresight of the ABH is needed.
- Savage and Parmenter decided that s20 requires
- foresight of serious harm
- intention to wound
- no mens rea
- intention or foresight that some harm might result
Show answer
intention or foresight that some harm might result. Some harm, not serious harm.
- Under R v Donovan, actual bodily harm must be
- permanent
- more than transient and trifling, though not necessarily permanent
- a broken bone
- a psychiatric illness
Show answer
more than transient and trifling, though not necessarily permanent. The CPS charging standard quotes this test.
- What is the maximum sentence for s20 unlawful wounding or inflicting GBH, in years?
Show answer
5 years. s20: 5 years (the same as s47); s18: life.
- Which of these is a specific intent offence?
- s18 wounding with intent
- s47 ABH
- s20 inflicting GBH
- Battery
Show answer
s18 wounding with intent. s18 can be committed only intentionally.
- What is a 'wound' for ss18 and 20?
Show answer
A break in the continuity of the whole skin.. The CPS charging standard definition.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- Crown Prosecution Service: Offences against the person, incorporating the Charging Standard
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.