All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)

Theft (1): appropriation, property, belonging to another

Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)

Theft is defined in s1(1) Theft Act 1968: dishonestly appropriating property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it. Sections 3 to 5 define the actus reus words.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Appropriation (s3)

Any assumption by a person of the rights of an owner. Assuming any one right is enough (*R v Morris*, 1983). Appropriation can happen even with the owner's consent (*Lawrence v MPC*, 1972; *DPP v Gomez*, 1993). Keeping or dealing with property as owner after coming by it innocently is also appropriation (s3(1)). A buyer in good faith for value is protected (s3(2)).

Property (s4)

Money and all other property, real or personal, including things in action and other intangible property.

Belonging to another (s5)

Worked example

Problem: Tia's employer mistakenly pays her an extra 500 dollars. She notices and spends it. Has she appropriated property belonging to another?

  1. Appropriation: spending the money is dealing with it as owner (s3(1)).
  2. Property: money is property (s4(1)).
  3. Belonging to another: under s5(4) property got by another's mistake, where there is a legal obligation to restore it, is treated as belonging to the person entitled (A-G's Reference No 1 of 1983).
  4. Conclusion: the actus reus is complete; liability depends on dishonesty and intention to permanently deprive (next lesson). If she had not noticed, she would not be dishonest (Moynes v Cooper).

Answer: Actus reus satisfied through s5(4).

Key idea: s3: appropriation = assuming any right of an owner, even with consent (Morris, Gomez). s4: property includes money and intangibles; not land, wild plants (unless commercial) or confidential information (Oxford v Moss). s5: belonging to anyone with possession, control or an interest, including s5(3) obligations and s5(4) mistakes.

Check yourself

  1. What did R v Morris decide about appropriation?
    • Assuming any one of the owner's rights is enough
    • All the owner's rights must be assumed
    • The goods must leave the owner's premises
    • The owner must object at the time
    Show answer

    Assuming any one of the owner's rights is enough. One right of an owner is enough.

  2. DPP v Gomez decided that appropriation
    • requires the owner to object
    • requires the goods to be moved
    • can occur even where the owner consents
    • cannot apply to shop goods
    Show answer

    can occur even where the owner consents. Following Lawrence v MPC.

  3. A worker memorises a rival's secret recipe from a document and leaves the document behind. Following Oxford v Moss, the recipe information is
    • not property, so it cannot be stolen
    • property, because it has value
    • land under s4(2)
    • a wild creature under s4(4)
    Show answer

    not property, so it cannot be stolen. Confidential information is not property for the Theft Act.

  4. An owner secretly takes back his own laptop from a repair shop to avoid paying the bill. Applying s5(1) and R v Turner (No 2), the laptop
    • could not be stolen because he owned it
    • was abandoned property
    • was covered by s4(3)
    • belonged to the shop, which had possession or control
    Show answer

    belonged to the shop, which had possession or control. You can steal your own property from someone in possession or control.

  5. Who commits theft under s4(3)?
    • A person who picks wild flowers for their own kitchen table
    • A person who picks wild mushrooms to sell at a market
    • A walker who picks wild blackberries to eat
    • A child who picks wild foliage for a school project
    Show answer

    A person who picks wild mushrooms to sell at a market. Wild plants are stolen only if picked for reward, sale or commercial purpose.

  6. Define appropriation under s3 Theft Act 1968.
    Show answer

    Any assumption by a person of the rights of an owner, including keeping or dealing with property as owner after coming by it innocently.. s3(1).

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.