All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)
Formation: offer and acceptance
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)
A contract needs agreement: an offer by one party accepted by the other. Problem questions often turn on whether a statement was an offer at all, whether it was still open, and when acceptance took effect.
Offer or invitation to treat?
An offer is a statement of the terms on which the offeror is willing to be bound. An invitation to treat only invites offers.
- Goods on display in a shop are an invitation to treat; the customer makes the offer at the till (*Pharmaceutical Society of GB v Boots*, 1953).
- Advertisements are generally invitations to treat (*Partridge v Crittenden*, 1968), but an advert can be a unilateral offer to the world, accepted by performing the act (*Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co*, 1893).
- A statement of the lowest price is not an offer if it shows no intention to be bound (*Harvey v Facey*, 1893).
- Tenders and auctions: each bid is an offer, accepted by the fall of the hammer; in an auction without reserve the auctioneer is bound to sell to the highest bidder (*Heathcote Ball v Barry*, 2000).
How an offer ends
- Revocation at any time before acceptance, if communicated, even by a reliable third party (*Dickinson v Dodds*, 1876). A unilateral offer cannot be revoked once the offeree has started performing (*Errington v Errington*, 1952).
- Counter-offer: it destroys the original offer (*Hyde v Wrench*, 1840).
- Lapse of time: an offer ends after a reasonable time (*Ramsgate Victoria Hotel v Montefiore*, 1866).
- Rejection, death, or failure of a condition.
Acceptance
Acceptance must be an unqualified agreement to all the terms (the mirror image rule) and must normally be communicated and received (*Entores v Miles Far East*, 1955).
- Silence is not acceptance (*Felthouse v Bindley*, 1862).
- Acceptance can be by conduct (*Brogden v Metropolitan Railway*, 1877).
- Postal rule: a properly addressed and stamped letter of acceptance takes effect when posted (*Adams v Lindsell*, 1818), but the offeror can exclude the rule, for example by requiring acceptance to reach them (*Holwell Securities v Hughes*, 1974).
Worked example
Problem: On Monday Kofi emails Lina offering his bike for 300 dollars, 'offer open until Friday'. Lina replies 'I'll pay 250'. Kofi refuses. On Wednesday Lina posts a letter accepting at 300. On Thursday Kofi sells the bike to Omar. Is there a contract with Lina?
- Issue: was Kofi's offer still open when Lina accepted?
- Rule: a counter-offer destroys the original offer (Hyde v Wrench).
- Apply: 'I'll pay 250' was a counter-offer, so Kofi's offer ended on Monday. Lina's letter is at most a new offer, which Kofi never accepted. The postal rule cannot help because there was no live offer to accept.
- Conclusion: no contract with Lina; Kofi may sell to Omar.
Answer: No contract: the counter-offer killed the original offer.
Check yourself
- A customer puts goods from a shelf into a basket. In Pharmaceutical Society of GB v Boots, where was the offer made?
- By the shop when it displayed the goods
- By the cashier when ringing up the price
- By the manufacturer through its packaging
- By the customer at the till
Show answer
By the customer at the till. Display is an invitation to treat; the customer offers to buy at the till.
- Why could Mrs Carlill enforce the Carbolic Smoke Ball advertisement?
- All adverts are offers
- It was a unilateral offer accepted by performing the conditions
- She had written to the company first
- The company had used silence as acceptance
Show answer
It was a unilateral offer accepted by performing the conditions. Carlill is the leading case on unilateral offers made to the world.
- Seller offers a car for 5,000. Buyer replies 'I will pay 4,500'. What is the effect?
- A contract at 4,500 is made
- A contract at 5,000 is made
- The offer stays open for a reasonable time
- The original offer is destroyed by a counter-offer
Show answer
The original offer is destroyed by a counter-offer. Hyde v Wrench: a counter-offer destroys the original offer.
- A letter of acceptance is posted on 3 March and arrives on 6 March. The offeror revoked by phone on 4 March. Under the postal rule, is there a contract?
- Yes, acceptance took effect on 3 March
- No, revocation came before receipt
- No, letters can never accept offers
- Only if the offeror read the letter
Show answer
Yes, acceptance took effect on 3 March. Adams v Lindsell: acceptance is complete on posting, before the revocation.
- A seller writes: 'If I hear nothing from you by Friday, I will treat my offer as accepted.' Which case says silence cannot be acceptance?
- Entores v Miles Far East
- Adams v Lindsell
- Felthouse v Bindley
- Harvey v Facey
Show answer
Felthouse v Bindley. Felthouse v Bindley: silence does not amount to acceptance.
- Which statement about revocation is correct?
- It must be communicated, and a reliable third party can communicate it
- It takes effect when the offeror decides to revoke
- It is impossible once a deadline is promised
- It can be made after acceptance
Show answer
It must be communicated, and a reliable third party can communicate it. Dickinson v Dodds: the offeree learned of revocation from a third party.
- Explain the difference between an offer and an invitation to treat.
Show answer
An offer shows an intention to be bound on acceptance, whereas an invitation to treat only invites the other party to make an offer, such as goods on display.. The test is intention to be bound.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Offer and acceptance
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.