All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)

Formation: consideration

Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)

English law enforces bargains, not bare promises. Each side must give something of value in the eyes of the law in return for the other's promise.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

The basic rules

Existing duties

Part payment of a debt

Paying part of a debt is not consideration for a promise to let off the rest (*Pinnel's Case*, 1602, affirmed in *Foakes v Beer*, 1884). Exceptions: payment early, in a different form or place at the creditor's request, or part payment by a third party (*Hirachand Punamchand v Temple*, 1911). The equitable doctrine of promissory estoppel can also prevent a creditor going back on a promise (*Central London Property Trust v High Trees House*, 1947, listed in Pearson's course planner).

Worked example

Problem: A builder is late on a fixed-price job and may face a penalty. The client, worried about delay, promises an extra 5,000 dollars if the builder finishes on time. The builder finishes on time. Can the builder enforce the promise?

  1. Issue: is finishing an existing contractual duty consideration?
  2. Rule: normally no (Stilk v Myrick), but a practical benefit to the promisor can be enough (Williams v Roffey).
  3. Apply: the client avoids delay, the cost of finding another builder and a penalty under its own contracts; these are practical benefits obtained without duress.
  4. Conclusion: the builder is likely to enforce the promise, though the client could argue the extra money was extracted under pressure.

Answer: Likely enforceable under Williams v Roffey.

Key idea: Consideration must be sufficient (not adequate), move from the promisee and not be past. Existing duties are not consideration unless exceeded or a practical benefit is gained. Part payment does not discharge a debt unless an exception or promissory estoppel applies.

Check yourself

  1. A house is sold for 1 dollar. Which rule from Chappell v Nestle explains why the promise can still be enforced?
    • Consideration must be past
    • Consideration must be sufficient but need not be adequate
    • Consideration must equal the market value
    • Consideration must move from a third party
    Show answer

    Consideration must be sufficient but need not be adequate. The court does not weigh the value of the bargain.

  2. After Ana repaints Ben's fence unasked, Ben promises to pay her 100. Is the promise enforceable?
    • Yes, the work had value
    • Yes, because promises are binding
    • No, because painting is a public duty
    • No, her consideration is past
    Show answer

    No, her consideration is past. Re McArdle: work done before the promise is past consideration.

  3. When can past consideration still be valid?
    • When the act cost a lot of money
    • When the act was done at the promisor's request and payment was understood
    • When it is written down afterwards
    • When the promise is made by a company
    Show answer

    When the act was done at the promisor's request and payment was understood. Lampleigh v Braithwaite: a prior request saves past consideration.

  4. What did Williams v Roffey Bros add to the existing duty rule?
    • Existing duties are always consideration
    • Part payment always discharges a debt
    • A practical benefit to the promisor can be consideration
    • Consideration need not move from the promisee
    Show answer

    A practical benefit to the promisor can be consideration. Williams v Roffey is an exception to Stilk v Myrick.

  5. A debtor owes 10,000 and the creditor agrees to accept 6,000 in full settlement on the due date. Under Foakes v Beer, the creditor can
    • later sue for the remaining 4,000
    • never claim more
    • claim only interest
    • claim only if the agreement was oral
    Show answer

    later sue for the remaining 4,000. Part payment on the due date is not consideration for releasing the balance.

  6. Using the figures in the Foakes v Beer question above (debt 10,000, accepted 6,000 on the due date), how much can the creditor still recover?
    Show answer

    4000 dollars. 10,000 - 6,000 = 4,000.

  7. Explain why performing an existing contractual duty is not normally good consideration.
    Show answer

    Because the promisee is already bound to do it, so they give nothing new in return for the extra promise (Stilk v Myrick).. The promisor receives nothing beyond what they were already owed.

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.