All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.7)
Occupiers' Liability Act 1957: lawful visitors
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.7)
The 1957 Act sets the duty an occupier owes to lawful visitors for dangers due to the state of the premises. Pearson's planner stresses that it creates a duty only: breach, causation and damage must still be proved.
Occupier, premises, visitor
- Occupier: whoever has sufficient occupational control of the premises; there can be more than one (*Wheat v Lacon*, 1966). Physical occupation is not needed (*Harris v Birkenhead Corp*, 1976).
- Premises: land and buildings, and fixed or movable structures, including vehicles, vessels and aircraft.
- Visitor: someone with express or implied permission (invitees and licensees) and people entering under a legal right, such as meter readers (s2(6)). Repeated trespass known to the occupier who does nothing may create an implied licence (*Lowery v Walker*, 1911), but repeated trespass alone is not enough (*Edwards v Railway Executive*, 1952). Since 1984 courts are reluctant to imply one (*Tomlinson*, 2003). People using public or private rights of way are not visitors under the 1957 Act.
The common duty of care (s2)
s2(2): to take such care as in all the circumstances is reasonable to see that the visitor will be reasonably safe in using the premises for the purposes for which he is invited or permitted to be there.
- Children (s2(3)(a)): the occupier must be prepared for children to be less careful than adults. An attractive but dangerous thing (an allurement) increases the risk: in *Taylor v Glasgow Corporation* (1922) a seven-year-old died after eating poisonous berries from an unfenced shrub in a public park; the council was liable. But responsibility for very young children rests primarily with parents (*Phipps v Rochester Corporation*, 1955).
- Skilled visitors (s2(3)(b)): an occupier may expect a person in the exercise of his calling to guard against risks ordinarily incident to it (*Roles v Nathan*, 1963).
Discharging the duty and defences
- Warnings (s2(4)(a)): a warning discharges the duty only if, in all the circumstances, it enables the visitor to be reasonably safe (*Roles v Nathan*). No duty to warn of obvious risks (*Darby v National Trust*, 2001).
- Independent contractors (s2(4)(b)): the occupier is not liable for a contractor's faulty work if it acted reasonably in entrusting the work and took reasonable steps to check the contractor was competent and the work properly done (*Ferguson v Welsh*, 1987; Pearson also cites *Haseldine v Daw*).
- Defences: consent, for risks willingly accepted (s2(5)); contributory negligence; exclusion by notice or contract (s2(1), *White v Blackmore*, 1972), but not for death or personal injury caused by negligence in a business context (UCTA s2(1)) or by a trader against a consumer (CRA s65).
Worked example
Problem: At a garden centre, Grace slips on spilled compost in an aisle with no warning sign. Her son Ollie, aged 5, wanders into a staff-only shed and is cut by a hedge trimmer left switched on. Sam, a glazier hired to replace a cracked glasshouse panel, is cut by the broken glass while removing it. Advise on the garden centre's liability under the 1957 Act.
- All three are lawful visitors (Ollie possibly exceeds his permission by entering the shed, so consider the 1984 Act for him too).
- Grace: unmarked spilled compost means the centre failed to take reasonable care for her safety (s2(2)); a warning or prompt cleaning might have discharged the duty (s2(4)(a)). Damages may be reduced if she was careless.
- Ollie: the occupier must expect children to be less careful (s2(3)(a)); an unattended running tool is an allurement-type danger (Taylor v Glasgow). But Phipps places primary responsibility for young children on parents, which may reduce or remove liability.
- Sam: the risk of cuts from broken glass is ordinarily incident to a glazier's calling (s2(3)(b), Roles v Nathan), so the centre is probably not liable to him.
Answer: Grace likely succeeds; Ollie arguable; Sam probably fails.
Check yourself
- Wheat v Lacon decided that an occupier is someone who
- owns the freehold of the land
- lives on the premises
- has sufficient occupational control of the premises, and there can be more than one
- pays the business rates
Show answer
has sufficient occupational control of the premises, and there can be more than one. Control, not ownership.
- The common duty of care in s2(2) requires the occupier to take reasonable care to see that the visitor
- will be reasonably safe in using the premises for the permitted purposes
- will never be injured on the premises
- is warned of every possible danger
- has insurance
Show answer
will be reasonably safe in using the premises for the permitted purposes. Reasonable safety for the permitted purpose.
- Why was the council liable in Taylor v Glasgow Corporation?
- The child was a trespasser
- The child's parents were present
- Poisonous berries in a public park attracted a child, and there was no fence or warning
- The berries were planted by a contractor
Show answer
Poisonous berries in a public park attracted a child, and there was no fence or warning. An allurement to a child entitled to be there, with a hidden danger.
- Roles v Nathan is authority that
- occupiers are liable for all injuries to workers
- an occupier may expect skilled visitors to guard against risks ordinarily incident to their calling
- warnings are never enough
- contractors are always liable instead of occupiers
Show answer
an occupier may expect skilled visitors to guard against risks ordinarily incident to their calling. s2(3)(b).
- An occupier hires a reputable lift engineer who negligently leaves the lift unsafe, injuring a visitor. Under s2(4)(b) the occupier is probably
- always liable for contractors
- liable only if the visitor is a child
- liable under strict liability
- not liable, if it acted reasonably in choosing and checking the contractor
Show answer
not liable, if it acted reasonably in choosing and checking the contractor. Ferguson v Welsh.
- Phipps v Rochester Corporation suggests that, for very young children,
- occupiers owe no duty at all
- responsibility for their safety rests primarily with their parents
- occupiers are always liable
- the 1957 Act does not apply
Show answer
responsibility for their safety rests primarily with their parents. Devlin J's view on prudent parents.
- When will a warning sign discharge an occupier's duty under the 1957 Act?
Show answer
Only if, in all the circumstances, it was enough to enable the visitor to be reasonably safe (s2(4)(a)).. s2(4)(a) and Roles v Nathan.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Occupiers' Liability Act 1957, section 2
- e-lawresources: Occupiers' liability
- e-lawresources: Taylor v Glasgow Corporation [1922]
- swarb: Phipps v Rochester Corporation (1955)
- legislation.gov.uk: Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977
- legislation.gov.uk: Consumer Rights Act 2015, Part 2 (unfair terms, ss 61 to 68)
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.