All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.8)
Occupiers' Liability Act 1984: trespassers and other non-visitors
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.3.8)
The 1984 Act governs the duty owed to people other than visitors, mainly trespassers. The duty is narrower than under the 1957 Act and covers personal injury only.
When a duty arises: s1(3)
The occupier owes a duty only if all three conditions are met:
- (a) he is aware of the danger or has reasonable grounds to believe it exists;
- (b) he knows or has reasonable grounds to believe that the other is in, or may come into, the vicinity of the danger; and
- (c) the risk is one against which, in all the circumstances, he may reasonably be expected to offer some protection.
These are judged at the time of the injury (*Donoghue v Folkestone Properties*, 2003). The duty can be owed even to someone breaking in with criminal intent (*Revill v Newbery*, 1996). The Act replaced the common law position in *British Railways Board v Herrington* (1972).
Content of the duty and defences
- s1(4): to take such care as is reasonable in all the circumstances to see that the person does not suffer injury on the premises by reason of the danger.
- s1(5): the duty may be discharged by taking reasonable steps to warn of the danger or to discourage people from incurring the risk.
- s1(6): no duty for risks willingly accepted (consent).
- s1(7): no duty to people using the highway.
- s1(8): no liability for loss of or damage to property.
Key cases
- *Tomlinson v Congleton BC* (House of Lords, 2003): a man dived into a shallow lake in a park despite 'No swimming' signs and broke his neck. No liability: the risk came from his own voluntary activity, not the state of the premises, and the council could not reasonably be expected to protect him from an obvious danger. Lord Hoffmann stressed the social cost of banning activities many people enjoy safely.
- *Ratcliff v McConnell* (1997): a student climbed over a locked gate at night into a college pool and dived into the shallow end. No liability: the danger of diving into shallow water was obvious, and a fence, locked gate and set opening hours were reasonable precautions.
Worked example
Problem: Teenagers regularly climb through a gap in the fence of a disused factory, which the owner knows about. A 15-year-old falls through a rotten floor and is badly injured. Is the owner liable under the 1984 Act?
- s1(3)(a): the owner knows or has reason to believe the floors are rotten in a disused building.
- s1(3)(b): he knows teenagers come through the gap, so they may come into the vicinity.
- s1(3)(c): a hidden danger in a building known to attract trespassing young people is a risk he can reasonably be expected to offer some protection against.
- s1(4) and (5): mending the fence or warning signs might have discharged the duty; he did neither. Unlike Tomlinson and Ratcliff, the danger was hidden and arose from the state of the premises. Conclusion: likely liable for the injury, possibly reduced for contributory negligence.
Answer: Likely liable: hidden danger, known trespassers, no precautions.
Check yourself
- Which is NOT one of the s1(3) conditions for a duty under the 1984 Act?
- The occupier is aware of the danger or has reasonable grounds to believe it exists
- The occupier knows the person may come into the vicinity of the danger
- The trespasser was a child
- The risk is one the occupier may reasonably be expected to protect against
Show answer
The trespasser was a child. Age is relevant to the facts, not a statutory condition.
- A trespasser's expensive camera is smashed when he falls through a rotten floor. Under the 1984 Act
- he cannot claim for the camera, because s1(8) excludes property damage
- he can claim for the camera only
- he can claim for everything
- the occupier owes him no duty because he is a trespasser
Show answer
he cannot claim for the camera, because s1(8) excludes property damage. The 1984 Act covers injury only.
- Why was the council not liable in Tomlinson v Congleton BC?
- The claimant was a lawful visitor
- There were no warning signs
- The risk came from the claimant's own voluntary act of diving, not the state of the premises
- The lake was privately owned
Show answer
The risk came from the claimant's own voluntary act of diving, not the state of the premises. Obvious risk from his own activity.
- Under s1(5), how may an occupier discharge the 1984 Act duty?
- Only by making the premises completely safe
- By taking reasonable steps to warn of the danger or discourage people from incurring the risk
- By putting up a notice excluding liability
- By calling the police
Show answer
By taking reasonable steps to warn of the danger or discourage people from incurring the risk. Warnings or discouragement.
- Revill v Newbery shows that the 1984 Act duty
- is never owed to burglars
- applies only to children
- covers property damage
- can be owed even to a person breaking in with criminal intent
Show answer
can be owed even to a person breaking in with criminal intent. Protection extends to criminal entrants, though contributory negligence may apply.
- Give two differences between the 1957 and 1984 Occupiers' Liability Acts.
Show answer
The 1957 Act protects lawful visitors and covers property damage; the 1984 Act protects trespassers and non-visitors, applies only if the s1(3) conditions are met, and covers personal injury only.. Who is protected, when and for what.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Occupiers' Liability Act 1984, section 1
- e-lawresources: Occupiers' liability
- e-lawresources: Tomlinson v Congleton Borough Council
- e-lawresources: Ratcliff v McConnell
- Pearson Edexcel IAL Law sample assessment materials, Issue 1, February 2015 (Paper 2: The Law in Action)
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.