All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.10)
Sanctions: custodial sentences, community orders, fines and discharges
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.10)
The specification lists the sentences available under the Criminal Justice Act 2003: custodial sentences, community orders, fines and discharges. Their rules are now consolidated in the Sentencing Act 2020 (the Sentencing Code), which the Sentencing Act 2026 has amended. Pearson wants these applied to offenders in a scenario.
Purposes of sentencing
For adult offenders the court must have regard to five purposes (originally s142 Criminal Justice Act 2003, now s57 Sentencing Act 2020):
1. punishment of offenders
2. reduction of crime, including by deterrence
3. reform and rehabilitation of offenders
4. protection of the public (including victims of crime, words added by s4 Sentencing Act 2026 from 22 March 2026)
5. making of reparation by offenders to persons affected by their offences
The duty does not apply to mandatory sentences or hospital orders.
The four types of sentence
| Sentence | Key rules | Main purposes served |
|---|---|---|
| Custodial | Immediate prison, or a suspended sentence order. For offenders convicted on or after 22 March 2026, the Sentencing Act 2026 means a sentence of 12 months or less must be suspended unless the court finds exceptional circumstances or an excluded case applies (for example a significant risk of harm to a particular person) (s1), and sentences of up to three years can now be suspended, up from two (s2) | Punishment; protection; deterrence |
| Community order | Only for imprisonable offences serious enough to warrant it; up to 3 years; at least one requirement (for example unpaid work of 40 to 300 hours, curfew, a probation requirement (called a rehabilitation activity requirement until September 2026), drug rehabilitation); a punitive element or fine normally required | Punishment; rehabilitation; reparation |
| Fine | A sum of money set by reference to the seriousness of the offence and the offender's means | Punishment; deterrence |
| Discharge | Absolute (no further action) or conditional: no punishment if no further offence is committed during a period of up to 3 years (s80 Sentencing Act 2020) | Used where punishment is unnecessary |
Sources: Sentencing Act 2020 ss57 and 80; Sentencing Act 2026 ss1 and 2 (legislation.gov.uk); Howard League; Sentencing Academy, Community orders
How a judge decides
Sentencing Council guidelines guide judges and magistrates step by step: assess culpability and harm to find the category and starting point, adjust for aggravating factors (for example previous convictions, offence committed on bail, vulnerable victim) and mitigating factors (for example no previous convictions, remorse, youth or age), then reduce the sentence for a guilty plea (s73 Sentencing Act 2020). Under the Sentencing Council guideline the maximum reduction is one third where the plea is indicated at the first stage of proceedings, normally falling to a maximum of one quarter after that and to a maximum of one tenth on the first day of trial. The maximum sentence set by statute is the ceiling (for example 7 years for theft, 10 years for fraud, life for robbery and s18).
Worked example
Problem: Joel, 19, with no previous convictions, pleads guilty at the first opportunity to stealing a 40-dollar phone charger from a supermarket. Evaluate the most appropriate sentence.
- Seriousness: low value theft, low harm and culpability; the custody threshold is not passed.
- Mitigation: youth, no previous convictions, and a guilty plea at the first stage, which earns the maximum one-third reduction under the Sentencing Council guideline.
- Options: a conditional discharge (if punishment is unnecessary) or a fine based on his means; a community order would be possible only if the offence were serious enough.
- Conclusion: a conditional discharge or a modest fine best fits the purposes of rehabilitation and deterrence; prison would be disproportionate.
Answer: A conditional discharge or a fine.
Check yourself
- What is the maximum period of a conditional discharge, in years?
Show answer
3 years. s80 Sentencing Act 2020: up to three years.
- What is the maximum number of hours of unpaid work in a community order?
Show answer
300 hours. 40 to 300 hours.
- After trial a judge would have imposed 30 months' imprisonment. The offender pleaded guilty at the first stage and receives the full one-third reduction. What is the sentence, in months?
Show answer
20 months. 30 x (1 - 1/3) = 20 months.
- Under the Sentencing Council guideline, what is the maximum reduction for a guilty plea indicated at the first stage of proceedings?
- One half
- One quarter
- One tenth
- One third
Show answer
One third. Up to one third at the first stage; normally up to one quarter after that, and up to one tenth on the first day of trial.
- Which is NOT one of the statutory purposes of sentencing adults?
- Reduction of crime, including by deterrence
- Retribution against the offender's family
- Reform and rehabilitation
- Making reparation
Show answer
Retribution against the offender's family. The five purposes concern the offender, crime, the public and victims.
- A conditional discharge means
- a short prison sentence
- unpaid work in the community
- a fine paid in instalments
- no punishment now, provided the offender commits no further offence during the set period
Show answer
no punishment now, provided the offender commits no further offence during the set period. If he reoffends during the period, he can be sentenced for the original offence too.
- Under the Sentencing Act 2026, what must normally happen to a prison sentence of 12 months or less?
- It must be served in full
- It must be suspended unless an exception applies
- It must be converted into a fine
- It must be doubled
Show answer
It must be suspended unless an exception applies. Sentencing Act 2026 s1 (new ss264A and 277A of the Sentencing Code): the presumption applies to offenders convicted on or after 22 March 2026.
- What is a community order?
Show answer
A sentence served in the community, lasting up to three years, with one or more requirements such as unpaid work, a curfew or rehabilitation activity.. Sentencing Act 2020; Sentencing Academy explainer.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Sentencing Act 2020, section 57 (purposes of sentencing: adults)
- legislation.gov.uk: Sentencing Act 2020, section 80 (conditional discharge)
- legislation.gov.uk: Sentencing Act 2026 (c. 2), Part 1 (ss1, 2 and 4 in force 22 March 2026)
- legislation.gov.uk: Sentencing Act 2026, section 2 (custodial sentences that may be suspended)
- Howard League for Penal Reform: What is changing under the Sentencing Act 2026 and when
- Sentencing Council: Reduction in sentence for a guilty plea, definitive guideline (first hearing on or after 1 June 2017)
- Sentencing Academy: Community orders explained
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.