All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.9)
General defences: voluntary and involuntary intoxication
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.9)
Intoxication is not really a defence: the question is whether, because of drink or drugs, the defendant lacked the mens rea. The answer depends on whether the intoxication was voluntary and whether the crime is one of specific or basic intent.
Voluntary intoxication
- Specific intent crimes (for example murder, s18, theft, robbery, s9(1)(a) burglary): voluntary intoxication can be used to show the defendant did not form the intent (*DPP v Beard*, 1920; *R v Lipman*, 1970 for murder). But a drunken intent is still an intent (*R v Sheehan and Moore*, 1975). If the defendant lacked intent for murder, he is usually convicted of manslaughter, a basic intent crime.
- Basic intent crimes (for example assault, battery, s47, s20, manslaughter, criminal damage): voluntary intoxication is no defence, because getting drunk is itself reckless (*DPP v Majewski*, 1977).
- Dutch courage: drinking to give yourself courage to commit a crime you have already decided on is no defence, even to murder (*AG for Northern Ireland v Gallagher*, 1963).
Involuntary intoxication
- Drink or drugs taken unknowingly (a spiked drink) or a prescribed or non-dangerous drug with an unexpected effect (*R v Hardie*, 1985) count as involuntary.
- Involuntary intoxication can be a defence to any crime, but only if the defendant lacked mens rea. If he still formed the intent, he is guilty: there is no defence just because the drug lowered his inhibitions (*R v Kingston*, 1994, House of Lords).
- Knowing you are drinking alcohol but underestimating its strength is still voluntary (*R v Allen*, 1988).
Intoxicated mistakes
A drunken mistaken belief in the need for self-defence cannot be relied on (*R v O'Grady*, 1987; *R v Hatton*, 2006). But where a statute allows an honest belief, such as s5 Criminal Damage Act 1971, a drunken belief can count (*Jaggard v Dickinson*, 1981).
Worked example
Problem: At a hotel wedding reception, Hamid drinks heavily, then goes behind the bar, a staff-only area, takes three bottles of champagne and hides them in his bag. He says he was too drunk to know what he was doing. Can intoxication help him?
- Theft and s9(1)(a) burglary (entering part of a building as a trespasser, R v Walkington) are specific intent crimes, so voluntary intoxication can be evidence that he did not form the intent (Beard).
- But a drunken intent is still an intent (Sheehan and Moore): hiding the bottles suggests he knew he was taking them to keep.
- If he lacked intent at entry, s9(1)(a) fails, and s9(1)(b) also needs theft, which needs intent.
- Conclusion: likely guilty if the jury finds he still formed the intent; a basic intent offence, such as smashing a glass door on the way, is not excused by voluntary intoxication (Majewski).
Answer: Possible for specific intent, but a drunken intent is still intent.
Check yourself
- Under DPP v Majewski, voluntary intoxication is no defence to
- murder
- s18 wounding with intent
- basic intent crimes such as s47 ABH
- theft
Show answer
basic intent crimes such as s47 ABH. Getting drunk is itself reckless.
- In R v Kingston the defendant's drink was secretly drugged, but he still formed the intent to commit the offence. He was
- guilty, because a drugged intent is still an intent
- not guilty, because intoxication was involuntary
- guilty only of a lesser offence
- not guilty, because he was disinhibited
Show answer
guilty, because a drugged intent is still an intent. No defence of involuntary intoxication where mens rea is present.
- A man buys a knife and a bottle of whisky, drinks to give himself courage, then kills his wife as planned. Following Gallagher
- he can only be convicted of manslaughter
- he has a defence of involuntary intoxication
- intoxication is no defence
- he lacked mens rea
Show answer
intoxication is no defence. Dutch courage.
- Pat takes a sleeping tablet expecting it to calm her, but it unexpectedly makes her aggressive and she damages a car. Following R v Hardie, her intoxication may be treated as
- voluntary, because she chose to take it
- involuntary, because the drug had an unexpected effect
- Dutch courage
- irrelevant, because criminal damage is strict liability
Show answer
involuntary, because the drug had an unexpected effect. Unexpected effect of a non-dangerous drug.
- A drunk man mistakenly believes he is being attacked and hits a stranger. Following O'Grady, his drunken mistake
- is a complete defence
- makes it involuntary intoxication
- turns assault into a specific intent crime
- cannot support self-defence
Show answer
cannot support self-defence. Drunken mistakes about the need to use force are not allowed.
- Distinguish crimes of specific intent from crimes of basic intent for intoxication.
Show answer
Specific intent crimes can only be committed with intention, so voluntary intoxication may show the intent was not formed; basic intent crimes can be committed recklessly, and voluntary intoxication is no defence because getting drunk is itself reckless.. Majewski and Beard.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Intoxication and criminal liability
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.