All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)
Theft (2): dishonesty and intention to permanently deprive
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.4)
The mens rea of theft has two parts: dishonesty (s2 and the common law test) and intention to permanently deprive (s6).
Dishonesty: s2
Section 2(1) says an appropriation is not dishonest if the defendant believes:
- (a) they have a legal right to deprive the other of it;
- (b) the owner would consent if they knew of the appropriation and its circumstances; or
- (c) the owner cannot be discovered by taking reasonable steps.
These beliefs are judged subjectively; they need not be reasonable (*R v Holden*, 1991; *R v Small*, 1987). Under s2(2), being willing to pay does not stop an appropriation being dishonest.
Dishonesty: the common law test
Outside s2, dishonesty is decided by the test from *Ivey v Genting Casinos* (2017), confirmed for criminal law by the Court of Appeal in *R v Barton and Booth* (2020):
1. What was the defendant's actual state of knowledge or belief as to the facts?
2. Given that belief, was the conduct dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people?
There is no longer a requirement that the defendant realised ordinary people would see it as dishonest, the second limb of the old *Ghosh* (1982) test. Pearson's June 2025 report gave no credit for Ghosh and preferred Barton and Booth.
Intention to permanently deprive: s6
- Treating the property as your own to dispose of regardless of the owner's rights counts, even if you plan to give it back (*R v Lavender*, 1994; *R v Marshall*, 1998).
- Borrowing counts only if it is for a period and in circumstances equivalent to an outright taking, a strict test (*R v Lloyd, Bhuee and Ali*, 1985); for example, returning a season ticket after it has expired.
- Taking money intending to repay with different notes still deprives the owner of the original notes (*R v Velumyl*, 1989).
Worked example
Problem: Bea takes 50 dollars from her employer's till on Friday to pay a taxi, meaning to put back 50 dollars of her own on Monday. Is she guilty of theft?
- Dishonesty, s2: she does not believe she has a legal right or that the employer would consent. Under Barton and Booth, given what she knew, ordinary decent people would regard taking till money without permission as dishonest.
- Intention to permanently deprive: she intends to return different notes, not the same ones (R v Velumyl).
- Willingness to repay does not remove dishonesty (s2(2) applies the same idea).
- Conclusion: likely guilty of theft, though the sum and her intention to repay may affect sentence.
Answer: Likely guilty: Velumyl and Barton.
Check yourself
- Which case confirmed that the Ivey test applies to dishonesty in criminal law?
- R v Ghosh
- R v Barton and Booth
- R v Lloyd
- R v Morris
Show answer
R v Barton and Booth. The Court of Appeal (2020) followed the Supreme Court's direction in Ivey.
- Under the Ivey test, the second question is whether
- the defendant realised others would think it dishonest
- the defendant had a legal right to the property
- the owner suffered loss
- the conduct was dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people
Show answer
the conduct was dishonest by the standards of ordinary decent people. An objective standard applied to the facts as the defendant believed them.
- Ruth takes a bike believing, wrongly, that the law lets her keep it because the owner owes her money. Under s2(1)(a)
- she is dishonest because the belief is unreasonable
- she is not dishonest if she genuinely held that belief
- her belief is irrelevant
- she must prove the debt in court first
Show answer
she is not dishonest if she genuinely held that belief. The belief need only be genuine (Holden).
- Max borrows a neighbour's lawnmower without asking, uses it for an afternoon and returns it undamaged. Under s6 and R v Lloyd, Max
- intends to permanently deprive because he did not ask
- is guilty because borrowing is always theft
- probably lacks intention to permanently deprive
- intends to permanently deprive because he used it
Show answer
probably lacks intention to permanently deprive. Borrowing is theft only when equivalent to an outright taking, a strict test.
- A manager takes cash from the safe meaning to replace it with other money next week. Under R v Velumyl
- he intends to permanently deprive the owner of the actual notes taken
- he is not guilty, because the owner loses nothing
- he is guilty only of fraud
- he lacks dishonesty as a matter of law
Show answer
he intends to permanently deprive the owner of the actual notes taken. Different notes are not the same property.
- Name two beliefs under s2(1) Theft Act 1968 that mean an appropriation is not dishonest.
Show answer
A belief that you have a legal right to deprive the owner, or that the owner would consent, or that the owner cannot be found by taking reasonable steps.. s2(1)(a), (b) and (c).
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- legislation.gov.uk: Theft Act 1968 (revised text)
- e-lawresources: The law of theft
- National Archives Find Case Law: Barton and Booth v R [2020] EWCA Crim 575 (Court of Appeal, 29 April 2020)
- UK Supreme Court press summary: Ivey v Genting Casinos (UK) Ltd [2017] UKSC 67 (25 October 2017)
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.