All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Judicial precedent: stare decisis, ratio decidendi, obiter dicta and the court hierarchy
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Judges also make law. Specification point 1.2.7 starts with how the doctrine of precedent works through the court hierarchy.
Key terms
- Stare decisis: 'stand by what has been decided'. Like cases should be decided alike, which gives certainty.
- Ratio decidendi: the rule or principle that explains the result of a case. It is the part that binds later courts. It is not the outcome itself (Supreme Court lecture, 2024).
- Obiter dicta: 'things said by the way': other remarks and reasoning, which are not binding but can be persuasive.
- Binding precedent: a ratio a later court must follow.
- Persuasive precedent: something a court may follow but need not: obiter dicta, decisions of lower courts, Privy Council decisions, and decisions from other countries.
Ratio and obiter in action
Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416: a district judge thought he was bound by passages in *Halsey v Milton Keynes General NHS Trust* (2004) saying courts could not compel unwilling parties to mediate. The Court of Appeal held those passages were obiter, not part of the binding reasoning, because *Halsey* was about costs. So they did not bind, and the Court held courts can order parties to engage in non-court dispute resolution, if this does not impair the essence of the right to a judicial hearing and is proportionate.
The hierarchy
| Court | Bound by | Binds |
|---|---|---|
| UK Supreme Court | Not strictly bound by its own decisions (1966 Practice Statement) | Every court below |
| Court of Appeal | Supreme Court; its own decisions, subject to Young v Bristol Aeroplane exceptions | High Court and below |
| High Court | Court of Appeal and Supreme Court | County Court, magistrates |
| Crown Court, County Court, magistrates | Higher courts | Generally create no binding precedent |
Willers v Joyce (No 2) [2016] UKSC 44. Decisions of the Privy Council are not binding but normally of great persuasive weight.
Privy Council decisions
The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council hears appeals from some Commonwealth countries and is usually made up of Supreme Court Justices. In Willers v Joyce (No 2) (2016) the Supreme Court said its decisions cannot bind English courts but are normally of great persuasive weight; an English court should not follow one that conflicts with a binding domestic decision, unless the Privy Council has expressly directed that its decision represents English law.
Worked example
A High Court judge finds a statement in a Court of Appeal judgment that was not needed for the decision. Must the judge follow it?
- Identify whether the statement is ratio or obiter.
- It was not needed to reach the result, so it is obiter.
Answer: No. Obiter dicta are persuasive only; the judge may follow it but is not bound, as Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil shows.
Check yourself
- The ratio decidendi of a case is
- anything the judge says in court
- the final order, such as 'appeal allowed'
- the legal principle that explains the decision
- the facts of the case
Show answer
the legal principle that explains the decision. The ratio is the rule explaining the result and binds lower courts.
- Obiter dicta are
- remarks not needed for the decision, which are persuasive only
- binding on every court
- the reasons of the dissenting judge only
- decisions of Parliament
Show answer
remarks not needed for the decision, which are persuasive only. 'Things said by the way.'
- In Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil (2023), the Court of Appeal held that the relevant passages in Halsey (2004) were
- the ratio, so binding
- overruled by the Supreme Court
- obiter, so not binding
- a statutory instrument
Show answer
obiter, so not binding. The passages were outside the binding reasoning, which was about costs.
- According to Willers v Joyce (No 2), decisions of the Privy Council are
- binding on every English court
- normally highly persuasive but not binding on English courts
- ignored by English courts
- binding only on the Supreme Court
Show answer
normally highly persuasive but not binding on English courts. Persuasive, usually very strong, but not binding.
- Which court's decisions bind the High Court?
- The County Court
- The magistrates' court
- The Crown Court
- The Court of Appeal
Show answer
The Court of Appeal. The High Court is bound by the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court.
- Explain what is meant by stare decisis and why it matters.
Show answer
Stare decisis means standing by previous decisions, so that like cases are decided alike, which gives certainty and fairness.. Standing by decisions gives certainty, consistency and fairness, and saves time.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- UK Supreme Court: Lord Burrows, Precedent and Overruling in the UK Supreme Court (Lord Toulson Memorial Lecture, 20 March 2024)
- Court of Appeal: Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416 (judiciary.uk)
- UK Supreme Court: Willers v Joyce (No 2) [2016] UKSC 44, judgment of 20 July 2016
- Judicial Office: The Judicial System of England and Wales, a visitor's guide (March 2021)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
- Pearson: Paper 1 exemplar answers with examiner commentary, Question 1 (judicial precedent)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.