All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Precedent: the Practice Statement, Young v Bristol Aeroplane and avoiding precedents
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Precedent would freeze the law if it could never change. This lesson covers how the top courts depart from their own decisions and how judges avoid following precedents, with cases.
The Supreme Court and the 1966 Practice Statement
From London Tramways v London County Council (1898) the House of Lords treated itself as bound by its own decisions. The Practice Statement of 26 July 1966 changed this: previous decisions would normally be binding, but the House could depart from them when it appeared right to do so, balancing certainty against injustice in a particular case. It applies equally to the Supreme Court (*Austin v Southwark*, 2010).
Examples:
- British Railways Board v Herrington (1972): occupiers owe trespassers a limited duty of care, overruling *Addie v Dumbreck* (1929).
- R v G (2003): overruled *R v Caldwell* (1982) on the meaning of 'reckless'; two boys aged 11 and 12 had been convicted under an objective test the House found unfair (House of Lords judgment).
- Knauer v Ministry of Justice (2016): seven Justices departed from *Cookson v Knowles* (1979) and *Graham v Dodds* (1983) on calculating damages for future loss, using the Practice Statement 'with no hesitation'.
- R v Jogee (2016): the law on joint enterprise had taken a 'wrong turn' in *Chan Wing-Siu* (1985) and *R v Powell and English* (1999); foresight is only evidence of intention to assist or encourage.
The court is 'very circumspect' (*Knauer*) and especially cautious in criminal law, where certainty matters (*Horton v Sadler*).
The Court of Appeal: Young v Bristol Aeroplane (1944)
The Court of Appeal is generally bound by its own decisions, with three exceptions (as restated in *Willers v Joyce*, 2016):
1. where two of its own earlier decisions conflict, it may choose which to follow;
2. it must refuse to follow its own decision that cannot stand with a later House of Lords (now Supreme Court) decision;
3. it may decline to follow its own decision made per incuriam (through oversight of a relevant statute or binding authority).
Avoiding a precedent
| Method | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Distinguishing | Showing the material facts are different, so the earlier ratio does not apply; the earlier decision stays binding. Any court can do it |
| Overruling | A higher court (or the Supreme Court using the Practice Statement) decides in a later case that an earlier legal rule was wrong |
| Reversing | A higher court overturns the decision of a lower court in the same case on appeal |
| Departing | A court not following its own earlier decision (Supreme Court under the Practice Statement; Court of Appeal within Young exceptions) |
In Pearson's exemplar answers, a 6/6 answer explained distinguishing, overruling and reversing, each with a case.
Worked example
Explain the difference between overruling and reversing.
- Overruling: a later case; the earlier rule is declared wrong (Herrington overruled Addie v Dumbreck).
- Reversing: the same case on appeal; the higher court changes the lower court's decision.
Answer: Overruling concerns a different, later case; reversing happens on appeal in the same case.
Check yourself
- In which year did the House of Lords issue the Practice Statement allowing it to depart from its own decisions?
Show answer
1966. 26 July 1966.
- Which case used the Practice Statement to overrule Addie v Dumbreck (1929)?
- British Railways Board v Herrington (1972)
- Fisher v Bell (1961)
- Pepper v Hart (1993)
- Smith v Hughes (1960)
Show answer
British Railways Board v Herrington (1972). Herrington: occupiers owe trespassers a limited duty of care.
- What did the House of Lords decide in R v G (2003)?
- It created the offence of conspiracy to corrupt public morals
- It allowed reference to Hansard
- It overruled R v Caldwell on the meaning of 'reckless'
- It abolished the marital rape immunity
Show answer
It overruled R v Caldwell on the meaning of 'reckless'. The objective Caldwell test was unfair, especially to children.
- Which is one of the exceptions in Young v Bristol Aeroplane?
- The Court of Appeal may ignore any Supreme Court decision it dislikes
- The Court of Appeal may decline to follow its own decision made per incuriam
- The High Court may overrule the Court of Appeal
- Magistrates may depart from High Court decisions
Show answer
The Court of Appeal may decline to follow its own decision made per incuriam. Per incuriam: made through oversight of relevant law.
- A judge says an earlier case does not apply because its material facts were different. This is
- overruling
- reversing
- consolidation
- distinguishing
Show answer
distinguishing. Distinguishing leaves the earlier precedent intact.
- In Knauer v Ministry of Justice (2016), the Supreme Court
- held it could never depart from House of Lords decisions
- departed from two House of Lords decisions using the Practice Statement
- reversed a magistrates' decision
- followed Cookson v Knowles
Show answer
departed from two House of Lords decisions using the Practice Statement. It departed from Cookson v Knowles and Graham v Dodds.
- Explain why the Supreme Court is cautious about using the Practice Statement in criminal cases.
Show answer
Criminal law needs certainty, because people must know in advance what is a crime, so changing the law could be unfair and unsettle convictions.. Horton v Sadler and the Practice Statement stress the special need for certainty in criminal law.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- UK Supreme Court: Lord Reed, Departing from Precedent (speech, 20 January 2023)
- UK Supreme Court: Lord Burrows, Precedent and Overruling in the UK Supreme Court (Lord Toulson Memorial Lecture, 20 March 2024)
- House of Lords: R v G [2003] UKHL 50
- UK Supreme Court press summary: Knauer v Ministry of Justice [2016] UKSC 9
- UK Supreme Court press summary: R v Jogee [2016] UKSC 8
- UK Supreme Court: Willers v Joyce (No 2) [2016] UKSC 44, judgment of 20 July 2016
- Pearson: Paper 1 exemplar answers with examiner commentary, Question 1 (judicial precedent)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2020
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, June 2024 (copy hosted by Exam Papers Practice)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.