All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Law and morality: the Wolfenden Report and the Hart and Devlin debate
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Should the law enforce morality? Specification point 1.1.12 centres on a 1957 report and the famous debate it started.
The Wolfenden Report (1957)
The Committee on Homosexual Offences and Prostitution, chaired by Sir John Wolfenden, reported in 1957. It recommended that private homosexual acts between consenting adults (aged 21 and over, according to Pearson's topic guide) should no longer be criminal. On prostitution it said the act itself harmed no one and should not be illegal, but street soliciting should remain an offence because it disturbed others. Its guiding principle (Britannica) was that the law should not try to enforce private morality; it should deal with conduct that offends public decency or disrupts public order. Its recommendations on homosexuality were enacted in the Sexual Offences Act 1967.
Devlin: law should protect shared morality
Lord Devlin, a judge, argued that 'without shared ideas on politics, morals, and ethics, no society can exist'. Society has a shared morality, and the law is entitled to protect it, whether immoral conduct happens in public or in private, because undermining shared morality threatens society itself. The topic guide notes he first agreed with Wolfenden but later changed his view, and that his approach is reflected in the majority in *R v Brown* (1993).
Hart: the liberal response
H L A Hart, following Mill, argued that the law should interfere with private conduct only where there is genuine harm to others or a public nuisance. Private immorality does not damage the morality of the state, so it should not be criminal. He was a pluralist: society should tolerate difference. He set out his case in *Law, Liberty and Morality*. The topic guide links Hart's approach to *R v Wilson* (1996), where a husband who tattooed his initial on his wife's buttock with her consent was not treated as committing a crime.
A third view, from Stephen, is that the law has a duty to prohibit conduct that society at large condemns.
Evaluating the debate
- For Devlin: some consensual conduct (Brown) is still prosecuted; Parliament legislates on moral issues such as abortion and assisted suicide.
- For Hart: the law has steadily withdrawn from private morality since Wolfenden (Sexual Offences Act 1967 and later reforms; same-sex marriage in 2013).
- Problems with Devlin: whose morality? Shared morality changes over time.
- Problems with Hart: the line between harm to self and harm to others is hard to draw.
- A strong conclusion takes a side and explains why, using cases.
Worked example
Use the Hart and Devlin debate to discuss whether consensual private conduct that causes minor injury should be criminal.
- Devlin: if it offends shared morality the law can prohibit it; reflected in the Brown majority.
- Hart: no harm to others, so it is a private matter; reflected in Wilson.
Answer: Devlin would allow prosecution to protect shared morality; Hart would not, as there is no harm to others. The courts have drawn the line differently in Brown and Wilson, which shows the debate is still live.
Check yourself
- In which year was the Wolfenden Report published?
Show answer
1957. The Wolfenden Report was published in 1957.
- Which Act enacted Wolfenden's recommendation on homosexual acts?
- Abortion Act 1967
- Human Rights Act 1998
- Street Offences Act 1959
- Sexual Offences Act 1967
Show answer
Sexual Offences Act 1967. Britannica and the topic guide: the Sexual Offences Act 1967.
- Devlin argued that
- the law should only prevent harm to others
- society may use the law to protect its shared morality, even in private
- law and morality have no connection
- only Parliament, never judges, can consider morality
Show answer
society may use the law to protect its shared morality, even in private. Shared morality holds society together, so the law may protect it.
- Hart's position in the debate drew mainly on the ideas of
- Thomas Aquinas
- John Austin's sovereign
- J S Mill
- Lord Devlin
Show answer
J S Mill. Hart applied Mill's harm principle.
- Wolfenden recommended that street soliciting should
- remain an offence because it disturbs others
- be legalised completely
- be dealt with only by civil law
- carry a mandatory prison sentence
Show answer
remain an offence because it disturbs others. Prostitution itself was not to be illegal, but public soliciting remained criminal.
- Which case does Pearson's topic guide link to Hart's approach?
- R v Brown (1993)
- Shaw v DPP (1962)
- R v Wilson (1996)
- R v Gibson (1990)
Show answer
R v Wilson (1996). In Wilson consensual tattooing between spouses was not treated as a crime: a private matter.
- Give one criticism of Devlin's view that the law should enforce shared morality.
Show answer
In a diverse society there is no single shared morality, and moral views change over time, so it is unclear whose morality the law should enforce.. Key criticisms: no single shared morality; morality changes; risk of majority intolerance against minorities.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Wolfenden Report
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, October 2019
- Pearson mark scheme: YLA1/01, Summer 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.