All subjects · Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Theories of law: utilitarianism (Bentham and Mill)
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/01 (Paper 1)
Utilitarians judge laws by their consequences: do they increase overall happiness? Specification point 1.1.11.
Bentham
Jeremy Bentham, the founder of modern utilitarianism: 'it is the greatest happiness of the greatest number that is the measure of right and wrong'. A good law is one whose consequences produce more happiness than unhappiness overall. Bentham also influenced Austin's command theory.
Utilitarianism fits the forward-looking theories of punishment: deterrence and rehabilitation are justified because they reduce future crime, so punishment is justified only if it does more good than harm.
Mill and the harm principle
J S Mill (*On Liberty*) argued that coercion must be controlled: the law should intervene only where a person's actions are likely to harm others. Harm only to yourself is your own choice. The topic guide notes he generally excluded omissions, with exceptions such as failing to give evidence in court. Mill's harm principle influenced the Wolfenden Report on private conduct between consenting adults, and Hart's side of the Hart and Devlin debate.
Evaluation
- Strength: gives a practical test for law reform: count the costs and benefits.
- Weakness: a majority's happiness can justify sacrificing a minority. English law refused that reasoning in R v Dudley and Stephens (1884), which rejected necessity as a defence to murder even though killing one person arguably saved others (Britannica).
- Pearson's guide notes that 'good' and 'happiness' are hard to define and measure.
- Mill's harm principle is hard to apply: is harm to health or 'morals' harm to others?
Worked example
A government proposes to ban a popular but harmless pastime because a small group finds it offensive. How would Mill respond?
- Mill asks whether the conduct harms others.
- Offence to a group is not the kind of harm that justifies coercion.
Answer: Mill would oppose the ban: the law should restrict liberty only to prevent harm to others, not to stop conduct some people dislike.
Check yourself
- Who said 'it is the greatest happiness of the greatest number that is the measure of right and wrong'?
- Bentham
- Aquinas
- Kelsen
- Devlin
Show answer
Bentham. Bentham founded modern utilitarianism.
- Mill's harm principle says the law should intervene only to
- enforce shared morality
- protect people from themselves in every case
- prevent harm to others
- punish all sin
Show answer
prevent harm to others. Self-regarding conduct is the individual's choice.
- Which theory of punishment fits most closely with utilitarianism?
- Deterrence
- Revenge
- Retribution
- Denunciation for its own sake
Show answer
Deterrence. Deterrence is justified by its good consequences: less crime.
- R v Dudley and Stephens (1884) is useful in a utilitarianism answer because it
- created the harm principle
- decided that utilitarianism is part of English law
- allowed killing to save others
- rejected necessity as a defence to murder despite a 'many saved' argument
Show answer
rejected necessity as a defence to murder despite a 'many saved' argument. Britannica: the case appears to have rejected necessity as a defence to homicide.
- Mill's ideas most clearly influenced which report?
- The Benson Commission (1979)
- The Wolfenden Report (1957)
- The Law Commission's 2015 report on public nuisance
- The Cullen Inquiry (1996)
Show answer
The Wolfenden Report (1957). Wolfenden adopted the view that private conduct between consenting adults is not the law's business.
- Explain one weakness of utilitarianism as a basis for law.
Show answer
It can justify harming a minority if that makes the majority happier, and happiness is very hard to measure.. Two classic weaknesses: the majority's happiness can override minority rights; happiness and 'good' are hard to define and measure.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification, Issue 4 (November 2021)
- Pearson: International Advanced Level Law, Getting Started guide (Paper 1 course planner)
- Pearson: IAL Law Topic Guide for Paper 1, Law and Morality
- Encyclopaedia Britannica: Regina v. Dudley and Stephens
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.