All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)

Formation: intention to create legal relations and capacity

Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)

Even with offer, acceptance and consideration, there is no contract unless the parties intended legal consequences and had capacity to contract.

Practise this in the app: instant marking and a fix for every mistake. Free, no email needed to start.

Practise this lesson

Presumptions about intention

Type of agreementPresumptionRebutted byCases
Social and domesticNo intention to be legally boundSpouses separated, especially where the agreement is written down (Merritt v Merritt, 1970); money shared with a person outside the family (Simpkins v Pays, 1955); a serious arrangement acted on, such as paying off a mortgage (Errington v Errington, 1952)Balfour v Balfour (1919); Jones v Padavatton (1969)
CommercialIntention to be legally boundClear words such as 'binding in honour only'Edwards v Skyways (1964); Rose and Frank v Crompton Bros (1925); Ferrera v Littlewoods Pools (1998)

Source: e-lawresources, Intention to create legal relations

Capacity: minors

A minor is under 18 (Family Reform Act 1969). Contracts with minors are generally not enforceable against them, with exceptions:

People who lack mental capacity or are very drunk may avoid contracts if the other party knew of the incapacity; necessaries must still be paid for at a reasonable price.

Worked example

Problem: Ravi (17) buys a top-of-the-range games console on credit and refuses to pay. Can the shop enforce payment?

  1. Issue: is the contract enforceable against a minor?
  2. Rule: only necessaries and beneficial contracts of service bind a minor; the seller must prove necessaries (Nash v Inman).
  3. Apply: a luxury games console is unlikely to be suitable to his actual requirements.
  4. Conclusion: the shop probably cannot enforce payment, but a court may order the console returned under the Minors' Contracts Act 1987.

Answer: Probably not enforceable; return of the console may be ordered.

Key idea: Social and domestic agreements are presumed not binding; commercial agreements are presumed binding. Both presumptions can be rebutted. Minors are bound only by necessaries and beneficial contracts of service.

Check yourself

  1. A husband, living happily with his wife, promises her a weekly allowance. Following Balfour v Balfour, the promise is presumed
    • not intended to create legal relations
    • binding as a commercial agreement
    • void for lack of capacity
    • unenforceable for past consideration
    Show answer

    not intended to create legal relations. Domestic agreements are presumed not to be legally binding.

  2. Why was the agreement in Merritt v Merritt binding, unlike Balfour?
    • It was a commercial agreement
    • The husband was a minor
    • The spouses had separated
    • The wife gave natural love and affection
    Show answer

    The spouses had separated. Separation rebutted the domestic presumption.

  3. A business agreement states it is 'binding in honour only'. The likely effect is
    • the commercial presumption of intention is rebutted
    • it is enforceable like any contract
    • it becomes a contract for necessaries
    • it is void for mistake
    Show answer

    the commercial presumption of intention is rebutted. Rose and Frank v Crompton Bros: honour clauses rebut the presumption.

  4. Simpkins v Pays is cited for rebutting the social and domestic presumption where
    • the agreement is binding in honour only
    • one party is a minor
    • the agreement was made by post
    • a third party outside the family is involved in the arrangement
    Show answer

    a third party outside the family is involved in the arrangement. A third party involved rebutted the presumption.

  5. In Nash v Inman, who had to prove the waistcoats were necessaries?
    • The minor
    • The tailor (the seller)
    • The minor's father
    • The court of its own motion
    Show answer

    The tailor (the seller). The seller bears the burden of proving necessaries.

  6. Under the Family Reform Act 1969, at what age does a person stop being a minor for contract law?
    Show answer

    18 years. Majority is 18.

  7. Give two ways the presumption against intention in a family agreement can be rebutted.
    Show answer

    If the parties have separated, or the agreement is written down or involves money shared with an outsider.. Merritt (separation and a written agreement) and Simpkins v Pays (money shared with an outsider).

Practise with instant feedback

Sources

Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.