All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)
Formation: intention to create legal relations and capacity
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.1)
Even with offer, acceptance and consideration, there is no contract unless the parties intended legal consequences and had capacity to contract.
Presumptions about intention
| Type of agreement | Presumption | Rebutted by | Cases |
|---|---|---|---|
| Social and domestic | No intention to be legally bound | Spouses separated, especially where the agreement is written down (Merritt v Merritt, 1970); money shared with a person outside the family (Simpkins v Pays, 1955); a serious arrangement acted on, such as paying off a mortgage (Errington v Errington, 1952) | Balfour v Balfour (1919); Jones v Padavatton (1969) |
| Commercial | Intention to be legally bound | Clear words such as 'binding in honour only' | Edwards v Skyways (1964); Rose and Frank v Crompton Bros (1925); Ferrera v Littlewoods Pools (1998) |
Source: e-lawresources, Intention to create legal relations
Capacity: minors
A minor is under 18 (Family Reform Act 1969). Contracts with minors are generally not enforceable against them, with exceptions:
- Necessaries: goods suitable to the minor's condition in life and actual requirements. In *Nash v Inman* (1908) a tailor could not recover for eleven waistcoats sold to a student who already had enough clothes; the seller bears the burden of proving the goods were necessaries.
- Beneficial contracts of service (education, training, employment) bind the minor.
- Under the Minors' Contracts Act 1987 a court may order a minor to return property acquired under an unenforceable contract.
People who lack mental capacity or are very drunk may avoid contracts if the other party knew of the incapacity; necessaries must still be paid for at a reasonable price.
Worked example
Problem: Ravi (17) buys a top-of-the-range games console on credit and refuses to pay. Can the shop enforce payment?
- Issue: is the contract enforceable against a minor?
- Rule: only necessaries and beneficial contracts of service bind a minor; the seller must prove necessaries (Nash v Inman).
- Apply: a luxury games console is unlikely to be suitable to his actual requirements.
- Conclusion: the shop probably cannot enforce payment, but a court may order the console returned under the Minors' Contracts Act 1987.
Answer: Probably not enforceable; return of the console may be ordered.
Check yourself
- A husband, living happily with his wife, promises her a weekly allowance. Following Balfour v Balfour, the promise is presumed
- not intended to create legal relations
- binding as a commercial agreement
- void for lack of capacity
- unenforceable for past consideration
Show answer
not intended to create legal relations. Domestic agreements are presumed not to be legally binding.
- Why was the agreement in Merritt v Merritt binding, unlike Balfour?
- It was a commercial agreement
- The husband was a minor
- The spouses had separated
- The wife gave natural love and affection
Show answer
The spouses had separated. Separation rebutted the domestic presumption.
- A business agreement states it is 'binding in honour only'. The likely effect is
- the commercial presumption of intention is rebutted
- it is enforceable like any contract
- it becomes a contract for necessaries
- it is void for mistake
Show answer
the commercial presumption of intention is rebutted. Rose and Frank v Crompton Bros: honour clauses rebut the presumption.
- Simpkins v Pays is cited for rebutting the social and domestic presumption where
- the agreement is binding in honour only
- one party is a minor
- the agreement was made by post
- a third party outside the family is involved in the arrangement
Show answer
a third party outside the family is involved in the arrangement. A third party involved rebutted the presumption.
- In Nash v Inman, who had to prove the waistcoats were necessaries?
- The minor
- The tailor (the seller)
- The minor's father
- The court of its own motion
Show answer
The tailor (the seller). The seller bears the burden of proving necessaries.
- Under the Family Reform Act 1969, at what age does a person stop being a minor for contract law?
Show answer
18 years. Majority is 18.
- Give two ways the presumption against intention in a family agreement can be rebutted.
Show answer
If the parties have separated, or the agreement is written down or involves money shared with an outsider.. Merritt (separation and a written agreement) and Simpkins v Pays (money shared with an outsider).
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Intention to create legal relations
- Wikipedia: Nash v Inman [1908] 2 KB 1 (case summary)
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
- Pearson YLA1/02 mark scheme, Summer 2021
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.