All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.8)
General defences: duress of threats and duress of circumstances
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.2.8)
Duress is a complete defence where the defendant commits a crime because of a threat of death or serious injury. It is not available for murder or attempted murder. Pearson's course planner notes that self-defence is not in the specification.
Duress of threats: the Graham test
Approved in *R v Graham* (1982):
1. Was the defendant compelled to act because he reasonably believed he had good cause to fear death or serious injury?
2. Would a sober person of reasonable firmness, sharing the defendant's characteristics, have responded in the same way?
Other rules:
- The threat must be of death or serious injury; threats to reveal secrets alone are not enough (*R v Valderrama-Vega*, 1985). Threats to the defendant's immediate family, or to someone close to him, can count (*R v Hasan*, 2005).
- The threat must be linked to a specified crime the defendant is told to commit (*R v Cole*, 1994).
- Immediacy and escape: the defence fails if the defendant could have taken evasive action or gone to the police. *R v Hudson and Taylor* (1971) took a relaxed view, but *R v Hasan* (2005, House of Lords) said courts should be stricter.
- Relevant characteristics are limited (*R v Bowen*, 1996).
When duress is not available
- Murder (*R v Howe*, 1987, overruling *DPP for NI v Lynch*) and attempted murder (*R v Gotts*, 1992).
- Voluntary association with criminals: a defendant who voluntarily joins a violent gang, or associates with criminals when he foresaw or ought reasonably to have foreseen the risk of being subjected to compulsion by threats of violence, cannot rely on duress (*R v Sharp*, 1987; *R v Hasan*, 2005). Becoming indebted to drug dealers is an example (*R v Ali*, 1995).
Duress of circumstances
The threat comes from the situation, not from a person demanding a crime. Recognised in *R v Willer* (1986) and *R v Conway* (1989); *R v Martin* (1989) confirmed the same Graham rules apply. It is available for all crimes except murder, attempted murder and some forms of treason (*R v Pommell*, 1995), judged on the circumstances as the defendant believed them (*R v Cairns*, 1999).
Worked example
Problem: Lee owes money to a gang he joined knowing they were violent. They tell him they will break his legs unless he steals a car that night. He does. Can he rely on duress?
- Threat: serious injury, linked to a specified crime (stealing the car), so the Graham test may be met.
- Escape: he had several hours and could have gone to the police; after Hasan, this counts strongly against him.
- Voluntary association: he joined a gang he knew was violent, so under Sharp and Hasan the defence is barred.
- Conclusion: duress fails; the threats may reduce his sentence.
Answer: No: voluntary association and a chance to escape.
Check yourself
- Which is part of the Graham test for duress?
- Did the defendant act reasonably in all the circumstances?
- Was the defendant drunk at the time?
- Was the threat made by a police officer?
- Would a sober person of reasonable firmness, sharing the defendant's characteristics, have responded the same way?
Show answer
Would a sober person of reasonable firmness, sharing the defendant's characteristics, have responded the same way?. The second, objective limb.
- Following R v Howe and R v Gotts, duress is NOT available for
- theft
- murder and attempted murder
- criminal damage
- s47 ABH
Show answer
murder and attempted murder. The two crimes excluded.
- A man threatens to reveal Dee's affair unless she smuggles drugs. Following Valderrama-Vega, duress
- is available, because any threat counts
- is available only for murder
- is available if Dee is timid
- is not available on that threat alone, because it is not a threat of death or serious injury
Show answer
is not available on that threat alone, because it is not a threat of death or serious injury. Threats must be of death or serious injury.
- What did R v Hasan (2005) decide about voluntary association?
- The defence is barred if the defendant foresaw or ought to have foreseen the risk of compulsion by threats of violence
- The defendant must have foreseen the exact crime he would be forced to commit
- Voluntary association never matters
- Only membership of terrorist groups bars the defence
Show answer
The defence is barred if the defendant foresaw or ought to have foreseen the risk of compulsion by threats of violence. Hasan overruled the narrower Baker and Ward approach.
- A driver speeds through a red light because an armed attacker is chasing his car. The most suitable defence is
- duress of threats
- intoxication
- duress of circumstances
- lawful excuse under s5
Show answer
duress of circumstances. The threat comes from the situation (Conway; Martin).
- Why can a person who voluntarily joins a violent gang not rely on duress?
Show answer
Because by choosing to associate with violent criminals he foresaw, or ought to have foreseen, the risk of being forced by threats of violence to commit crimes, so he is at fault for being in that position.. Sharp and Hasan.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: The defence of duress
- Pearson IAL Law Getting Started guide (Paper 2 course planner, content notes and case lists)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.