All subjects · Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.2)
Terms: express, implied, conditions, warranties and innominate terms
Edexcel IAL Law · YLA1/02 (Paper 2, 2.1.2)
Once a contract exists, you must decide what its terms are and how important each term is, because that decides the remedy for breach.
Term or mere representation?
A pre-contract statement may be a term (breach gives a contract claim) or a representation (a false one may be a misrepresentation). Factors:
- Importance to the other party: *Bannerman v White* (1861).
- Special knowledge: a statement by an expert dealer is more likely a term (*Dick Bentley v Harold Smith Motors*, 1965) than one by a private seller with less knowledge (*Oscar Chess v Williams*, 1957).
- Timing: a long gap before contracting suggests a representation (*Routledge v McKay*, 1954).
- If the contract is written, oral statements left out tend to be representations.
Implied terms
- Implied in fact where necessary for business efficacy (*The Moorcock*, 1889) or so obvious that an officious bystander would say 'of course' (*Shirlaw v Southern Foundries*, 1939).
- Implied by custom of a trade (*Hutton v Warren*, 1836).
- Implied in law into a type of contract (*Liverpool CC v Irwin*, 1977).
- Implied by statute: the Consumer Rights Act 2015 (next lessons).
Classifying terms
| Type | Meaning | Remedy on breach | Case |
|---|---|---|---|
| Condition | Goes to the root of the contract | Terminate and claim damages | Poussard v Spiers (1876) |
| Warranty | Minor, collateral term | Damages only | Bettini v Gye (1876) |
| Innominate term | Classified by the effect of the breach | Terminate only if deprived of substantially the whole benefit | Hong Kong Fir Shipping v Kawasaki (1962) |
Source: e-lawresources, Conditions, warranties and innominate terms; the June 2025 examiner report credited Bettini and Poussard
Worked example
Problem: Priya, a caterer, agrees to supply a three-course dinner for Marcus's charity gala, served on linen tablecloths. She serves every course on time, but on paper tablecloths. Can Marcus end the contract and refuse to pay?
- Issue: is the term about the tablecloths a condition or a warranty?
- Rule: breach of a warranty gives damages only (Bettini v Gye); breach of a condition, one going to the root of the contract, allows termination (Poussard v Spiers). The June 2025 examiner report credited these two cases on a terms question.
- Apply: the main purpose of the contract, feeding the guests at the gala, was achieved; the tablecloths are a minor, collateral matter. If Priya had not turned up at all, the breach would go to the root, as in Poussard.
- Conclusion: likely a warranty, so Marcus can claim damages for the difference but cannot terminate or refuse to pay.
Answer: Warranty: damages only.
Check yourself
- Breach of a condition allows the innocent party to
- terminate the contract and claim damages
- claim damages only
- claim nothing unless the term is in writing
- renegotiate the price only
Show answer
terminate the contract and claim damages. A condition goes to the root of the contract (Poussard v Spiers).
- Bettini v Gye is the standard authority that breach of a warranty gives
- a right to terminate and claim damages
- a right to rescind for misrepresentation
- damages only
- no remedy at all
Show answer
damages only. A warranty is a minor term.
- Under the innominate term approach in Hong Kong Fir, the innocent party may terminate if
- the breach deprives it of substantially the whole benefit of the contract
- the term is labelled a warranty
- any breach occurs
- the contract is a consumer contract
Show answer
the breach deprives it of substantially the whole benefit of the contract. The court looks at the effect of the breach.
- A car dealer tells a buyer the car has done 20,000 miles; it has done 100,000. The statement is likely to be a term because
- the buyer was an expert
- it was made a month before the sale
- it was an opinion
- the dealer had special knowledge
Show answer
the dealer had special knowledge. Dick Bentley v Harold Smith Motors: the maker's expertise makes it a term.
- The Moorcock (1889) is authority for implying a term
- by trade custom
- to give the contract business efficacy
- by the Consumer Rights Act 2015
- whenever it would be reasonable
Show answer
to give the contract business efficacy. A term is implied only where necessary for business efficacy.
- What is an innominate term?
Show answer
A term that is not classified in advance as a condition or warranty; the remedy depends on how serious the consequences of the breach are.. Hong Kong Fir Shipping v Kawasaki.
Sources
- Pearson Edexcel International Advanced Level in Law specification (YLA1), Issue 4, November 2021
- e-lawresources: Contractual term or representation
- vLex: Dick Bentley Productions Ltd v Harold Smith (Motors) Ltd, Court of Appeal, 3 March 1965 (judgment text)
- e-lawresources: Terms implied by common law
- e-lawresources: Conditions, warranties and innominate terms
- Pearson YLA1/02 examiner report, June 2025 series (published August 2025)
Last updated 8 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.